-
Schwab’s US dividend equity ETF requires more than just basic dividend capabilities.
-
The Vanguard Dividend Appreciation ETF, despite modest yields, still offers value.
-
However, the Vanguard High Dividend ETF doesn’t really cater to newcomers looking for solid dividends.
If you’re in need of dependable investment returns that appreciate over time, dividend stocks usually come to mind. Yet, purchasing and holding individual dividend stocks can be a bit of a hassle for many investors. A collection of dividend stocks through ETFs provides a simpler alternative that can yield similar results.
That said, not all dividend ETFs are created equal. Each major ETF has its unique criteria for selecting its holdings, which can significantly impact performance. Some ETFs may align better with your goals than others.
With that in mind, let’s focus on two notable dividend-oriented ETFs that are currently appealing for income-seeking investors, and we’ll delve into one to be cautious about. The Schwab US Dividend Equity ETF, with yields falling below 3.8%, meets some crucial requirements for many income investors, though better yields can be found elsewhere.
This ETF leans heavily on major companies like Chevron, AbbVie, tobacco leader Altria, and PepsiCo. These are part of the ETF’s main positions, and while its setup is influenced by the Dow Jones US Dividend 100 Index, it holds significant names. Of course, adjustments happen during quarterly rebalancing.
Building an ETF based on this index is interesting. While it primarily looks for reliable dividend payments, dividend growth isn’t the sole criterion. The Dow Jones and S&P analyze eligible stocks based on cash flow and return on equity, which shapes the investment landscape.
This methodology appears effective. The result? A selection of value stocks that, despite not showing rapid revenue growth, still display solid growth. In fact, this Schwab fund has appreciated by about 45% over the past five years and has surged over 130% in the last decade.
Additionally, reinvesting dividends during this period has likely contributed an additional 60% to 70%. This performance continues to hold up against the S&P 500. Considering the risk level and the overall value of the fund, the trade-offs can be well worth it for income-focused investors seeking relative safety.
With around $100 billion in assets, the Vanguard Dividend Appreciation ETF is a favorite among dividend-focused ETFs. It’s easy to see why. The fund includes some of the most reliable dividend payers in the market, including Broadcom, Microsoft, and JPMorgan, whose quarterly dividends have nearly doubled over the last decade.
During this time, ETF prices have climbed by 186%, providing significant capital gains. This mainly stems from holding a few tech stock dividend payers that have benefited from trends like cloud computing and AI advancements.
However, there’s a catch. The yield on this ETF currently sits just over 1.6%, and it hasn’t exceeded 2% since late 2018. You could definitely come across higher yields.
The lower yield largely arises from how S&P selects stocks for its US Dividend Growers Index. While it aims to include companies that have raised dividends for ten consecutive years, stocks facing potential growth limitations get excluded, which is a reasonable standard.
Nevertheless, this remains relevant for investors as it offers above-average long-term capital gains. It might not be the best option for those seeking immediate income. If you’re more inclined toward consistent returns, the Vanguard High Dividend ETF may not be your best choice right now.
I know it sounds ironic, but this fund often fails to deliver high yields, with its average 30-day yield pegged at around 2.5%. Schwab’s offerings tend to focus on quality, dividend-paying companies, but they still seem to outperform this particular Vanguard fund.
But don’t overthink this lackluster yield too much. It’s a touch unusual. Before last year, yields were usually in the range of 2.7% to 3.3%. Some of its major holdings, like JPMorgan and Broadcom, have seen their prices drop significantly since late 2023, which has affected overall dividend growth.
Also, being a cap-weighted index can be challenging. The biggest companies often absorb much of the market gains while overshadowing others.
That said, this doesn’t mean the Vanguard High Dividend ETF isn’t worth considering. The underlying index is sound, but unusual market behavior since the latter half of 2023 has inflated the fund’s price and strained its yield. It might take a while for this to stabilize. In the meantime, there are other attractive dividend options out there.
So, make sure to think carefully before diving into Schwab’s US dividend equity ETFs.
According to Motley Fool’s analyst team, they have pinpointed what they believe are ten promising stocks to buy now, and Schwab’s US dividend equity ETF isn’t one of them. The selected stocks may yield substantial returns over the coming years.
For context: If you had invested $1,000 in Netflix when it was recommended back in December 2004, you’d have about $671,288 today. Similarly, if you did the same for Nvidia from April 2005, you’d have around $1,031,659. Remarkable, right?
It’s noteworthy that Stock Advisor has a return rate of 1,056%, significantly outperforming the S&P 500’s 185%. Don’t miss out on the latest recommendations if you’re looking for solid investment opportunities.
*Stock Advisor returns as of September 8, 2025.
