University Course on Tolkien Sparks Controversy
A university in the UK is facing criticism after it was reported that a class aimed at “decolonizing” the works of J.R.R. Tolkien is set to launch. The course, which is scheduled for 2024, is called “Imagining ‘Britain’: Decolonizing Tolkien et al.” and is led by Associate Professor Onyeka Nubia from the University of Nottingham.
This course proposes to dive into the myths and legends of the British Isles as portrayed by 20th-century authors, not just Tolkien but also C.S. Lewis, known for “The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe.” One of the key objectives is to explore British mythology, and if needed, rethink it through a decolonizing lens. It sounds a bit ambitious, doesn’t it?
The course description indicates that students will be encouraged to reinterpret these literary myths—viewing them as fantasies and even examining them through the lens of ancient and medieval understandings of various cultures, gender issues, and more. However, this has, understandably, raised some eyebrows.
In fact, there’s been a ripple effect of backlash. Some fans and critics of Tolkien are already expressing their discontent. There are mentions of similar courses being offered, like one titled “Imagining Britain: Decolonizing and Repopulating the Myth of the British Isles,” for the academic year of 2025-26, which omits Tolkien’s name from its title but echoes the same themes. It feels like a way to keep the conversation alive, but I wonder how it’ll be received.
Reports have surfaced that the curriculum includes assertions claiming Tolkien’s work embodies “ethnic chauvinism,” particularly against orcs and characters of darker complexion. Allegations indicate that Tolkien’s narrative style perpetuates discriminatory views, with some suggesting a divide between light-skinned and darker-skinned representations in his tales.
The discussion surrounding Tolkien isn’t new, as he has often been scrutinized in the context of politics and race. Recently, there have even been claims linking his literature to far-right extremism, prompting concerns from governmental bodies.
Attempts to reach out to the University of Nottingham and Professor Nubia for comments have yet to receive a response. It seems like this topic is going to spark more debates as it continues to unfold.
