Anthony Duclair’s Struggles Continue with Islanders

Expectations were somewhat unrealistic when it came to Anthony Duclair’s return this season. Coming back from a tough injury-filled 2024-2025, the hopes that he would quickly regain his form and become the 25-goal, 40-point player the Islanders anticipated signing last July, were perhaps a little too optimistic.

Now, after 11 games into the season, Duclair’s performance isn’t drastically different from last March, when he played through a painful torn groin that frustrated coach Patrick Roy. At 30 years old, Duclair has netted three goals and maintains an average of around 1.1 points per 60 minutes, which is marginally better than last season. But, it’s not just about the numbers; he seems to vanish during games.

His expected goals percentage at 5-on-5 is troubling at 35.28, especially when he’s receiving substantial ice time alongside Matt Barzal, who holds a higher xGF rating of 47.47.

After struggling on Barzal’s line, Duclair was bumped down to the fourth line in a recent game against Washington, joining the second power-play unit, while Cal Ritchie took his place. With Max Shabanov anticipated to return from injury soon, questions about Duclair’s spot in the lineup are becoming more pressing.

“I think I’m getting better every game,” Duclair remarked recently, expressing a sense of urgency for improvement. He feels he needs to be more aggressive and get to the net more often, yet he also claims his confidence is steadily rising.

Although he insists his groin feels normal, it’s common for players coming back from injuries to carry a shadow of doubt in their game. Kyle Palmieri, a teammate who has been through similar situations, commented on the challenges that come from returning after an extended absence. For him, adjusting back into the rhythm is crucial, even when health isn’t in question.

Unlike others who get hurt mid-season, Duclair had the summer to rehabilitate—though he admits his plans didn’t unfold perfectly. He completed a strong training camp, unexpectedly not joining the team late in the season.

“Speed-wise, I think I’m doing okay,” Duclair mentioned. “I’m putting in the work to prepare for practices and games. I believe my skating is decent, but sometimes it’s about utilizing that skill more effectively.”

When it comes to finding open plays, Palmieri noted that being comfortable and familiar is key. Missing time often leads to timing issues that are hard to overcome.

One fact stands out—being on the fourth line likely isn’t a long-term solution for Duclair.

In his prime, Duclair’s game was defined by speed, skill, and scoring. Yet, with a mere 9 minutes and 13 seconds of ice time in a recent outing, having him play on the fourth line seems counterproductive. If he can’t break out of this slump, there’s a lingering question about what the team’s next steps will be.