The NFL trade deadline is looming, and it raises a question for the Giants: Are they buyers or sellers?
As they stand at a disappointing 2-7, there are several ways the Giants could pivot their strategy. Here’s a breakdown of the possible moves.
Buyer?
The conventional wisdom that teams out of the playoff race would trade players for future draft picks is perhaps becoming old-fashioned. Take the Bears, for example; they traded Montez Sweat in October 2023, and his new team quickly negotiated an extension before he hit free agency.
The Giants might choose not to offload their impending free agents, but the idea of bringing in new players—especially receivers—could be on the table if the conditions are right, preferably with contracts extending through 2026.
Joe Schoen, the general manager, finds himself in a position with little to lose.
It could be beneficial for the Giants if they can acquire someone to assist in developing Jackson Dart and perhaps alleviate some pressure off the coaching staff. Even if Schoen is let go post-trade, he has enough resources to replace himself.
So, the ownership should clarify Shane’s situation before endorsing any significant moves.
A leading candidate for trading is Dolphins receiver Jaylen Waddle, who has a hefty $50 million commitment until 2028. There are reports suggesting the Dolphins are more amenable to trading Waddle since they let go of their general manager last week, though the asking price might be steep—potentially a first-round pick along with other assets. Given the Giants’ likely early second-round pick, perhaps bundling it with another mid-tier pick could satisfy the Dolphins.
However, Waddle may attract multiple bidders, complicating matters for the Giants, who are still in need of multiple improvements.
Then there’s Saints receiver Chris Olave; his concussion concerns might make the Giants hesitant.
If Dart ends up holding onto the ball too long and succumbs to hits, with only Wan’Dale Robinson showing capacity to get open, it could lead to dire consequences.
Brian Daboll, the head coach, stated, “I’m focused on improving with the current players.”
Do You Sell Big Fish?
Kayvon Thibodeau is under a one-year contract worth $14.75 million for 2026. With Brian Burns and Abdul Carter also in line for significant financial commitments, it seems unlikely the Giants will pursue extending Thibodeau’s contract, which might result in tough negotiations ahead.
Thibodeau voiced, “I want to be here.”
According to The Athletic, inquiring teams have been told the cost for Thibodeau would be a first-round pick, which feels excessive for someone with just eight sacks over the last 21 games. Thus, it appears the Giants will continue using their three-edge rotation.
Burns mentioned, “When your name comes up in trade talks, it weighs on your mind. Yet, the focus needs to stay on your skills.”
Meanwhile, Dexter Lawrence reiterated his desire to remain with the team, despite a challenging week dealing with external pressures from former Giants players and the disappointment of consecutive losses.
His value remains intact since his breakout in 2022, although his average annual salary of $21.8 million has become less of a steal with just half a sack recorded this season.
Lawrence’s contract situation is evolving, as he ranks among the highest-paid defensive tackles, and the added preseason incentives complicate matters further.
He’s confident in his performance, with analytics showing he’s facing double teams more than any other player this season.
Would Schoen entertain offers if a first-round pick came along?
Quarterback Trade?
Russell Wilson was benched after starting three games but hasn’t sought a trade. His next team would only owe him less than $1 million by season’s end.
Jameis Winston, sitting as a third-stringer, is projected to back up Dart next year. The Giants turned down trade offers for Winston during the preseason.
It’s unclear which playoff contenders genuinely need a starting quarterback. The Bengals opted for Joe Flacco, overlooking Wilson, who may be better off staying in a supportive role rather than being a backup elsewhere.
A “Better Atmosphere” Deal?
Will the Giants recognize their losses by moving on from Evan Neal, Jalin Hyatt, and Deonte Banks?
First off, they’d need to make an offer, perhaps a late-round pick swap. Secondly, Schoen has to deal with the fallout from previous drafting decisions instead of trying to hide them. Lastly, there’s no pressing need for these players now.
Neal struggled this season, failing at right tackle before sliding to the third team as a right guard.
Hyatt, despite being under contract until 2026, has fallen behind practice squad players in the depth chart.
The 49ers, fresh off a visit, might have interest in both players, according to league reports. Meanwhile, there were talks about Neal with the Raiders, but they didn’t progress.
Banks, already under contract through 2026, had to step up recently due to cornerback injuries, but his tackling issues have hurt his trade value.
