The first year of Donald Trump’s second presidential term is shaping up to be one of the most memorable in U.S. history. A lot of it seems to stem from how Trump has consistently made those who criticize him look unprepared or misguided.
For decades, following Franklin Delano Roosevelt’s presidency, it felt like presidents were just caretakers of democracy. But Trump took a different stance when he witnessed the dysfunction in Congress over something as simple as lunch location decisions.
Despite what the mainstream media might suggest, his bold moves appear to be yielding positive outcomes, which probably gives him optimism for the years ahead.
One year after returning to the Oval Office, Trump’s team claims all key campaign promises have been kept.
Here are five instances where Trump faced skepticism, yet things turned out differently than predicted.
1. Border Closure
Prior to Trump’s administration, Democrats contended that shutting down the border would require Congressional approval, and most experts agreed with that assessment.
David Marcus: Trump recognizes that security benefits all Americans, not just a few.
For instance, in 2024, Alberto Benitez from George Washington University Law School asserted that the president lacked the authority to unilaterally close the border.
This was proven wrong. For the seventh consecutive month, no illegal immigrants have been allowed entry into the country, according to Customs and Border Protection—zero, not even a handful.
It’s really astonishing, although we often brush aside incredible occurrences like this. Still, Trump made it a reality.
Morning Glory: Trump has become ‘the ultimate punisher.’
2. Tariffs
Last spring, on what Trump branded as “Emancipation Day,” he rolled out tariffs on almost every nation, causing the stock market to dip sharply. Speculation ran wild that his approval ratings would also take a nosedive.
Every channel and business magazine forecasted dire economic consequences, warning of a return to the Great Depression.
David Marcus: The reasons behind Trump’s sustained popularity despite this downturn.
“This is a catastrophe. Anyone claiming otherwise is lying,” the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee declared at that time.
However, those hefty tariffs opened doors to about $4 trillion in trade deals. Regardless of these deals, the stock market has reached unprecedented heights, and Wall Street remains diverse.
3. Bombing Iran
Critics on both sides of the aisle raised alarms that an attack on Iran could lead to chaos in the Middle East, possibly igniting World War III.
Liz Peek: Trump’s efforts are isolating Iran while prioritizing America.
Ryan Crocker, an expert in foreign affairs, cautioned that aerial strikes alone were insufficient to terminate Iran’s nuclear ambitions, suggesting that military action could force Iran into negotiating limits.
Yet again, Trump’s approach proved effective while experts faltered.
The U.S. military under Secretary of War Pete Hegseth successfully dismantled a nuclear program that previous administrations had merely attempted to contain.
As it stands, Trump’s refusal to heed expert advice left Iran’s regime teetering.
4. Crime in Washington D.C.
Last year, Washington D.C. saw a 40% drop in its homicide rate, second only to Denver. Over much of that year, Trump deployed the National Guard, aiming to enhance security for residents.
But what did the experts at the time predict regarding the National Guard’s involvement?
David Marcus: Border security can significantly cut overdose fatalities, yet Trump doesn’t receive acknowledgment.
David Kennedy, a criminal justice professor, warned that insufficient policing could lead to a spike in violence, expressing concerns about the Guard’s presence.
While experts claimed the Guard wasn’t positioned in high-crime areas, Trump took cues from Rudy Giuliani’s effective strategies in the 1990s.
The results were notable: from mid-August to mid-October, shootings in D.C. plummeted 62% compared to the previous year, highlighting the effectiveness of the Trump administration’s tough policies.
David Marcus: How many lives has Trump’s border strategy saved?
5. Cabinet
Whether it’s Pete Hegseth, Tulsi Gabbard, or others, nearly all of Trump’s cabinet choices faced skepticism, often labelled as sycophantic by critics on the left.
“We’re in uncharted territory,” political scientist Jonathan Hanson mentioned a year ago, questioning when standards might be crossed.
Rebecca Grant: Trump’s major national security achievements by 2025.
In fact, Trump’s cabinet stands out as one of the most effective in recent times, achieving significant successes as previously mentioned. Also, televised Cabinet meetings showcased their efforts.
The expert class insisted on traditional candidates, hoping to maintain the status quo even while feigning innovation.
For more insights, click here.
Yet, Trump is unlikely to adhere to those expectations in his second term.
Americans can hope that Trump continues to navigate challenges that perplex the established expert community.
Experts may not always champion Mr. Trump, but his focus on American interests consistently defies their predictions.
