Mayor Reflects on Irish Struggles Amid Israel-Hamas Tensions

On Tuesday, Mayor Zoran Mamdani drew parallels between the Irish experience and what he described as a “genocide” in Palestine, using the St. Patrick’s Day celebrations as a platform to address what he called the “deafening silence” surrounding the Israel-Hamas conflict.

During a breakfast at Gracie Mansion with former Irish President Mary Robinson, Mamdani softened his comments regarding Gaza. He made a poignant observation: “Who can better understand those who cry than those who have been made to cry for so long? The narrative of the Irish people, whether in Ireland or New York City, reflects a history of oppression and discrimination.”

He expressed admiration for Robinson, who served as Ireland’s first female president in the 1990s, praising her commitment to human rights and her advocacy for Palestine. “I mention this because, for years now, we have witnessed a genocide unfold, and yet many have chosen to remain silent,” Mamdani stated.

He continued, “Silence is not new for those who advocate for universal human rights for Palestinians. Too often, they are left alone and in tears, but former President Robinson has always spoken out.”

Mamdani also took a moment to appreciate the contributions of Irish New Yorkers in his mission for justice.

Robinson highlighted that global conflicts continue to affect many, mentioning regions like Iran, Lebanon, Palestine, Ukraine, and Sudan. “These struggles resonate deeply with many Irish people. Our own history is filled with memories of famine and conflict. Perhaps that’s why we recognize the suffering of others so easily—the pain of displacement, the quest for dignity and self-determination,” she said during the breakfast attended by around 50 people.

She emphasized the need for community rather than division, urging people to develop the moral courage necessary to support peace and uphold human dignity. “That courage exists in everyday people, and in Ireland, we’ve seen it diminish among those who doubt a more just future can exist,” she noted.

Mamdani’s remarks came just before he was set to participate in a Catholic Mass with NYPD Chief Jessica Tisch and join the Fifth Avenue parade. Just the day before, when asked about his stance on a united Ireland, which aims to consolidate all 32 counties, he admitted, “To be honest, I haven’t thought about that question enough.”