Radical progressives often claim that America lacks a distinct culture, viewing it merely as a reflection of whatever is currently popular. If this is the case, then why do so many activists focus on erasing Western civilization instead of merely adjusting its political landscape? Contrary to what some might think, America is far more than an empty vessel. It embodies a rich heritage that reflects the foundations of Western civilization, which is why efforts against this heritage are so pronounced.
Open hostility toward the cultural underpinnings of a nation isn’t something to ignore. For instance, Mahmoud Khalil, a pro-Palestinian activist, led a coalition at Columbia University with the explicit aim of eradicating Western civilization. This begs the question: Why single out the West instead of just targeting America? To many, America is the fulcrum of Western ideals—it’s often viewed as the most prominent example of Western progress.
As Russell Kirk famously articulated, the United States has woven together diverse traditions from significant centers of thought and culture in the West. From Jerusalem, we received the Judeo-Christian moral framework and the concept of a covenant under God. Athens contributed the ideals of rational thought, while Rome offered republican governance and the rule of law. The founders in Philadelphia skillfully blended these influences to form a constitutional republic anchored in Judeo-Christian values. In essence, America did not emerge from nowhere; it developed from a specific civilizational foundation.
This achievement, however, isn’t without its critics. Throughout history, many non-Western societies have grappled with political and economic barriers that stifle innovation and opportunity, often benefiting when they adopt Western principles like rule of law and stable governance. Daron Acemoglu and James A. Robinson, in their work on state failures, assert that poor governance primarily arises from extractive systems that favor an elite minority at the expense of the populace. Instead of recognizing this, some point fingers at Western culture, framing it as a source of colonization and oppression, while conveniently overlooking the historical context, such as the relatively brief era of modern Western colonialism and the eventual abandonment of empires in favor of independence.
Even as the West gets blamed for global challenges, it paradoxically remains a destination for countless people seeking a better life.
The issue of importing anti-Western sentiments is becoming increasingly prominent in the U.S. Many activists and immigrants embrace the freedoms available here while simultaneously rejecting the civilization that gives rise to those freedoms. The previous administration even aimed to address this but faced significant backlash. Ultimately, nations need more than mere tolerance of dissent against their cultural roots; they must actively safeguard these foundations.
A country that loses faith in its origins risks losing them entirely. If the U.S. hopes to endure beyond current political cycles, it must foster a renewed appreciation for its Western heritage and carefully consider its immigration policies. A society that welcomes those who wish to dismantle its core values invites inevitable decline.
