Senate Republicans Test Commitment to Voter ID Legislation
Senate Republicans are putting Senate Democrats’ resolve to the test regarding voter ID legislation. Senate Minority Leader John Thune (R-S.D.) asserts this is the only viable way forward, though it might not align with what many constituents hope for.
Thune is feeling pressure from various fronts, including President Donald Trump, fellow Senate Republicans, and a dedicated online conservative community urging for a talking filibuster to pass the Protecting American Voter Eligibility Act (SAVE). However, Thune has noted that this floor tactic has historically not succeeded in advancing legislation.
Debate Begins Without Retreat
Thune expressed doubt about the effectiveness of a talking filibuster, saying, “Nobody knows how this is going to end. Even the people who say they know don’t know.” He pointed out that it’s unprecedented, or at least hasn’t occurred in modern times.
Proponents of the talking filibuster believe it could help overcome the Senate’s 60-vote margin needed to pass the SAVE America Act, but it carries a significant cost: valuable floor time. This precious commodity is something lawmakers are hesitant to forfeit amid a government shutdown.
Thune mentioned that Senate Democrats, under former Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.), have contemplated such a strategy in the past but ultimately chose not to pursue it, feeling it wasn’t worth the potential repercussions.
Republicans Challenge Democrats’ Stance
Thune remarked, “If I see a path, even if it’s a small percentage chance of success, I’ll consider it.” He added, however, that extensive research revealed no cases in recent Senate history where a “walk-the-talk” filibuster led to passed legislation.
Consequently, Senate Republicans are engaging in a form of talking filibuster. This approach allows for open debate but prohibits significant amendments from Senate Democrats that could alter the bill, as Republicans know they wouldn’t have the votes needed to defeat it.
Thune’s leadership style emphasizes collaboration within the party rather than unilateral decision-making, a practice that has facilitated his rise to the top Republican position in the Senate.
Pressure Mounts as Senate Moves Forward
While some critics are disappointed that the Republican strategy doesn’t lower the threshold for passage, Thune is unwilling to cave to external pressures to initiate a full filibuster, aiming to manage realistic expectations instead.
The Republican game plan involves holding three days of continuous discussion on the SAVE America Act, intending to compel Senate Democrats to publicly oppose the measure. As for when this debate will conclude, that remains uncertain.
Sen. Mike Lee (R-Utah), who is one of the bill’s main sponsors, believes the Senate should take as long as necessary to discuss the legislation fully. “If we’re not there yet, then we need to keep having the conversation,” he stated.
