White Castle, a beloved fixture in Queens for nearly 90 years, will close its doors on Wednesday, marking the end of one of New York City’s longest-running eateries.
The fast-food establishment opened in 1939 on 57th Street in Elmhurst and is expected to be sold and replaced by an apartment building, according to restaurant manager Elsa Lima.
A sign on the building announced, “This store is closed. We’re happy to serve you,” urging patrons to visit their locations in Brooklyn and Sunnyside.
On Tuesday night, the dining area was largely empty, with only a large soda machine and some kitchen equipment filling the space.
White Castle, which operates over 25 locations in New York, revealed that the decision to sell its cherished Queens site came as its value surged.
Jamie Richardson, the chief marketing officer, explained that with rising values, it’s prudent to consider offers from potential buyers.
He also mentioned that current employees would have opportunities for new roles within the company.
“As these changes occur, White Castle will reinvest the sale proceeds to focus on business growth and provide a great workplace,” Richardson stated.
However, this announcement surprised local residents, many of whom view the fast-food joint as a community staple.
James McMenamin, an Elmhurst resident, expressed that the closure signifies “the end of an era” and highlights the “drastic” changes taking place along Queens Boulevard.
“I think this iconic spot opened around the time of the 1939-40 World’s Fair. It’s well-known in a nostalgic landscape that’s evolving quickly,” he commented.
Online, people shared their memories and feelings about the restaurant’s closure.
“My grandfather used to take us there when we were little. Sad day,” one user reflected.
Others echoed similar sentiments, reminiscing about their experiences growing up around the restaurant.
Local historian Michael Perlman noted that while the White Castle in Elmhurst opened in 1939 and underwent several renovations, including one just a year ago, it seems illogical to abandon its rich cultural history.
Despite its long history, the Elmhurst location isn’t the oldest in New York City. That title goes to the White Castle on Fordham Road in the Bronx, which has been serving customers since 1930.
Founded in Wichita, Kansas in 1921 by Walt Anderson and Billy Ingram, White Castle is recognized as the world’s first fast-food hamburger chain, best known for its signature small square “sliders.”
