We're now at the point in the NFL season when teams are looking ahead. Some are for the playoffs and beyond, while others are for the NFL Draft or free agency. In recent memory, quarterback play took a backseat in his first season. Total offense is king, and a one-dimensional passing attack is no longer enough to consistently win on Sundays.
Still, even with the increased value of line play and running backs, quarterbacks are still king in the league. As we wrap up 2024 and head into 2025, we're taking a closer look at what each team's quarterback situation looks like and how they can be divided into tiers.
please remember this it's not Rank players based on talent alone. The idea is not to differentiate between Patrick Mahomes and Jordan Love, but to understand that neither the Chiefs nor the Packers need to think about doing anything at the QB position other than adding depth. That's it.
fully configured
Needless to say, each of these teams doesn't have to worry about the QB situation at all. In both cases, we're talking about teams with established top-level passers who don't require much attention. Barring a serious injury or unexpected collapse, they could lead the organization for the next five to 10 years.
“Good” with quotation marks
These are all legitimately good people, but it's fair to debate them. While not necessarily a player to consider replacing, there are some concerns here that tend to fall into a few different buckets.
- Are they better off-plan? Brock Purdy, Bo Nix, Jayden Daniels
- Inconsistent play, but really high level when playing: Kyler Murray, Dak Prescott
- Will he be able to stay healthy? tua tagovailoa
There's no reason not to start these, but setting them as full locks is just a little questionable.
what's the plan?
These are (mostly) established starters, but the team Really You need to start thinking about succession planning. No one in this group has a bright future waiting for them.
good? bad? who knows?
Rookies, sophomores, and players riding the pine behind established starters. We still don't really know about all these players what It's not a solution yet, but I think it will be close by the end of this season or next season. At least teams like Minnesota and Atlanta. someone Build around it.
mid
There's nothing wrong with Baker Mayfield. Statistically, you could be fooled into thinking he's an elite quarterback. The truth is, he's just…fine. The Bucks are in a unique position, as they have players with great offensive skills at the position, making it very easy for players below center.
There's probably an argument to be made that Baker belongs to that group. “Good” with quotation marks But I'm worried about putting him on the same level as other players.
garbage
On the plus side, neither the Raiders nor the Giants have a lot of money tied up in a garbage QB situation.
overpaid garbage
It's trash, but you get it. It doesn't look good.
deshaun watson
You're paying Deshaun Watson. Nothing can save you from that.
