Senate to Vote on ACA Subsidies Amid Concerns Over Rising Premiums

With many Americans increasingly anxious about next year’s health insurance premiums, Congress is contemplating an extension of subsidies linked to the Affordable Care Act (ACA).

The Senate is set to hold a vote this week on health care subsidies as the deadline approaches. Approximately 24 million individuals rely on the ACA Marketplace, and they have until December 15 to select a plan. However, many shoppers, like Amy Jackson from Butler, Missouri, are feeling uncertain about their potential costs. In a recent conversation with NPR, she expressed her concerns about insurance expenses with and without ACA subsidies.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED NPR CONTENT)

Amy Jackson: Right now, I’m looking at around $300, but before tax credits, it was about $1,250.

Serena Simmons Duffin: So that’s an extra $1,000 a month?

Jackson: No, it’s… not really.

As this situation unfolds, NPR’s Luke Garrett is on the scene at the Capitol. Hello, Luke.

LUKE GARRETT: Hi, Miles.

Parks: What will the Senate be voting on this week?

GARRETT: The Senate plans to vote on a proposal by Democrats aimed at prolonging ACA tax credits for three years. This measure could keep health insurance costs stable for people like Amy Jackson. Minority Leader Chuck Schumer indicated that the vote is scheduled for Thursday, framing it as Republicans’ “last chance” to address what he refers to as “insurance inflation.”

Parks: But Schumer is the minority leader. Why is he the one deciding on the timing for this vote?

GARRETT: Well, a while back, moderate Democrats negotiated a deal to reopen the government after a lengthy shutdown. As part of that agreement, a vote on the ACA was promised for early December, and now we’re at that point. Schumer is leveraging this three-year extension proposal for that vote. The challenge for Democrats is that they need some Republicans to reach the necessary 60 votes.

Parks: What’s the Republican stance on extending ACA subsidies?

GARRETT: Senator John Thune, the Senate Majority Leader, recently commented that Schumer’s plan isn’t realistic. Pennsylvania’s Republican Senator Dave McCormick voiced similar sentiments on Fox News.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

Dave McCormick: The Democrats are putting on a show right now, proposing a three-year extension of subsidies.

GARRETT: Nonetheless, McCormick stressed the need for Congress to find a viable solution to the rising ACA premiums.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

McCormick: I believe we should address this issue for working families. I support some limited extension to reform these subsidies.

GARRETT: There’s been noticeable momentum among Republicans for a temporary solution to the expiring ACA subsidies, but consensus remains elusive.

Parks: What about President Trump? Has he weighed in on this topic?

GARRETT: Trump has generally taken a back seat, making sporadic comments on social media. He’s maintained a critical view of the ACA and suggested sending funds to U.S. health savings accounts instead. Louisiana Senator Bill Cassidy mentioned he’s working to incorporate Trump’s ideas into the legislation soon.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

BILL CASSIDY: We’re aiming to present a plan to Leader Thune and Speaker Johnson that empowers Americans to choose lower premiums and HSAs. We’ll likely get that out tonight.

GARRETT: However, when I asked the White House about Cassidy’s proposal, Press Secretary Khush Desai didn’t address it directly. Instead, she remarked that the health care system isn’t functioning well, emphasizing that the president is focusing on lowering prescription drug costs.

Parks: What should we be looking for next week?

GARRETT: Thune indicated that Republicans will have a plan, but we’ll have to see how that unfolds. Even if he secures a majority, Democrats will still need to be on board. The moderate senators who negotiated with Republicans previously are crucial here. Even if an agreement is reached in the Senate, it would still need to pass in the Republican-led House, and the president would have to sign it. Overall, there’s a significant undercurrent of dissatisfaction regarding escalating costs, which could either foster bipartisan legislation or lead to political consequences on Capitol Hill.

Parks: Thank you, NPR’s Luke Garrett.

GARRETT: Thank you.