A mysterious illness linked to breast implants has symptoms similar to multiple sclerosis, but important questions remain

A mysterious illness linked to breast implants has symptoms similar to multiple sclerosis, but important questions remain

Christina Applegate says she wonders whether her breast implants might be contributing to her health problems, though she has not established that they are the cause.

On a Nov. 10 episode of “MeSsy,” the podcast she co-hosts with actress and MS advocate Jamie-Lynn Sigler, Applegate said she believes it may be time to replace her implants. She had a double mastectomy in 2008 after being diagnosed with breast cancer. She also recently came across research suggesting that symptoms associated with implants can resemble those of multiple sclerosis (MS).

Applegate said she has sometimes worried that her implants might be leaking and affecting her health. She plans to raise the possibility with her doctors, but said no one has confirmed a link.

Her symptoms include joint pain, trouble lifting her right arm and pain that can make it difficult to get out of bed. She said she currently cannot move her right shoulder or lift her arm.

Applegate also mentioned rheumatoid arthritis, lupus and Lyme disease as other possible explanations. She and her doctors are starting over with testing and considering conditions that can resemble MS. The number of possibilities, along with the pain, feels overwhelming, she said.

Diana Zuckerman, president of the National Center for Health Research and a breast implant safety advocate, said breast implant illness has received more attention in recent years. Symptoms vary, she noted, and can include joint pain, persistent fatigue, brain fog, memory problems, anxiety, insomnia, muscle pain and weakness. Some of these symptoms can also occur with other illnesses.

Zuckerman said patients often report experiencing several symptoms at once. Some women have said they felt dramatically better after their implants were removed, she added.

Plastic surgeon Jonathan Kaplan said patients’ symptoms are real, but that blood tests cannot predict who will develop problems related to implants. For people dealing with fatigue, pain or cognitive symptoms, he recommends first investigating other treatable explanations, including MS or medication side effects.

Removing implants may help, Kaplan said, but improvement after surgery is the only way to establish whether they were contributing to someone’s symptoms. If the patient does not improve, they may have undergone surgery without benefit. He said there is currently no evidence that the presence or absence of implants affects MS.

Kaplan described a patient who developed fatigue and blood test results that suggested kidney problems several years after receiving implants. After having them removed, she felt better and her test results returned to normal. However, he said, there was no test that could have predicted her risk beforehand.

Patricia McGuire, a St. Louis plastic surgeon and chair of the Breast Implant Emergency Task Force, said patients have reported more than 100 symptoms they associate with breast implant illness. There are no established diagnostic criteria, she said, and the condition is considered a diagnosis of exclusion rather than a formally recognized illness.

Reported symptoms have been associated with all types of implants, including silicone and saline models, and with implants from different manufacturers. The cause remains unknown. Possible explanations that have been proposed include metals, bacterial or fungal infections, allergic reactions, immune responses to a foreign object and psychiatric factors. Some patients do report feeling better after removal, McGuire said.

In a prospective, blinded study co-led by McGuire and Dr. Caroline Glicksman, researchers found no biological differences—such as metals, bacteria or inflammatory markers—between patients reporting symptoms and a group without symptoms. McGuire said participants did experience symptom relief after removal, while the research also found links with anxiety, patterns of physical symptom reporting and substantial reliance on social media for health information.

The researchers had hoped to identify a clear, reversible cause or a blood test that could help diagnose the condition, McGuire said. Pilot studies are now underway in hopes of finding more definitive answers.

In 2021, the FDA introduced stricter labeling requirements for breast implants, including a boxed warning and a patient decision checklist. The warning lists possible systemic symptoms such as fatigue, memory loss, rash, brain fog and joint pain, and notes that they may improve after implant removal.

Breast implants are not considered lifetime devices. The FDA recommends MRI or ultrasound screening five to six years after surgery, followed by screening every two to three years, to check for ruptures that may not cause obvious symptoms. However, implants do not automatically need to be replaced after 10 years if they remain intact and the patient has no symptoms.

McGuire advised people with implants who develop symptoms to have a thorough medical evaluation to look for treatable causes before considering surgery. Anyone considering removal should consult a board-certified plastic surgeon with experience in breast surgery.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News