After the playoff, Indiana still can’t escape debate over its schedule, while Alabama once again avoids the conversation

After the playoff, Indiana still can’t escape debate over its schedule, while Alabama once again avoids the conversation

The College Football Playoff committee had another opportunity this week to explain the metrics behind its rankings, which have sparked debate across the sport for several weeks. One question loomed large: would Indiana climb back into the top five after beating USC at home?

It didn’t. Instead, attention turned to Alabama, which stayed at No. 3 despite a shaky weekend. The Crimson Tide’s six SEC wins all came against teams that lost last Saturday, and Alabama struggled on the road against Vanderbilt while playing without starting quarterback Keelon Russell.

Indiana, meanwhile, moved from ninth to eighth after its 27-13 win over USC. The committee’s explanation for the Hoosiers’ earlier drop focused in part on their strength of schedule and the fact that their Big Ten opponents had lost recently. That reasoning is harder to square with Alabama holding its position after a difficult outing and a poor weekend for its previous opponents.

Indiana coach Curt Cignetti has clearly grown tired of hearing that his team’s schedule is too easy. He said Monday that he has heard the criticism for years and believes people are too quick to dismiss what the Hoosiers have achieved.

The committee appears to think Indiana hasn’t done enough against its schedule, and that argument may continue until conference championship weekend. The rankings also reflect a lot of faith in the SEC’s strength: four teams from the conference sit in the top 12, while several four-loss teams remain in the Top 25. South Carolina, for example, is ranked 21st after losing 34-6 to Arkansas without quarterback LaNorris Sellers.

There are still plenty of ways the SEC picture could change. If LSU beats No. 9 Tennessee in Knoxville this weekend, the Vols could be pushed out of playoff contention. Depending on other results, the conference might end up with only three teams in the field.

Texas, currently fifth, should be favored against Arkansas, while Alabama’s toughest remaining regular-season test appears to be its game against Auburn next week. South Carolina’s matchup with Georgia might have carried major playoff implications, but the Gamecocks’ loss to Arkansas took much of the intrigue out of it. Georgia has already secured a playoff place and will be looking to finish SEC play without injuries.

For the SEC to land four teams in the playoff, Tennessee likely needs to beat LSU. Kentucky also weakened its case by losing to Florida last weekend.

The Big 12 could be back in the conversation for more than two playoff teams after No. 12 Texas Tech routed Oklahoma State. If No. 10 BYU beats Kansas and Texas Tech wins at Baylor, the final weeks of the regular season could leave the committee with some difficult choices.

No. 2 Utah is in a strong position and could potentially absorb a loss in the Big 12 championship game. BYU and Texas Tech have less room for error, though. Both likely need to win their remaining regular-season games if the conference hopes to put three teams in the playoff.

The Big Ten picture is less settled than it might have seemed. No. 4 UCLA and No. 8 Indiana are currently the conference’s two teams in the top 12, but No. 13 Oregon could still make a late push. If the Ducks beat Michigan State and Washington, they may have a case for a playoff spot, even without Dante Moore.

Oregon could still have to get past Iowa in the rankings. If the Hawkeyes win their final two games against Illinois and Nebraska, they may have a strong argument of their own. Ohio State, sitting at No. 14, also has an outside chance, although its path looks difficult.

Committee chair Hunter Yurachek said Ohio State benefited from a home win over Northwestern and from losses by teams ranked above it. Whether the Big Ten earns more than two playoff spots may come down to a turbulent finish to the regular season.

It’s a strange turn of events: the Big 12 may have a better chance than the Big Ten of placing more than two teams in the postseason. Indiana’s move to eighth, while Alabama remained third, only added to the questions. The committee said it was impressed by Indiana’s offense against USC, and the Hoosiers did move ahead of Tennessee. Still, the contrast with Alabama’s unchanged position is hard to ignore.

In the end, the remaining games will settle much of this. Wake Forest is one team worth watching. The Demon Deacons have played well over the past month, and their win over SMU strengthened their case, even if their schedule has been a concern.

Wake Forest needs Duke to beat Clemson and must take care of business against Georgia Tech. A loss by Miami could make the situation more interesting in a hurry.

Another week has passed, and several teams remain just outside the playoff picture. Alabama’s ranking will keep prompting questions, at least until the season’s final stretch plays out. College football has a way of making the last few weeks matter.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News