Detroit received the news it had been dreading Monday: Aidan Hutchinson tore his ACL while celebrating a sack against the Patriots in Germany and will miss the rest of the season. It’s a huge setback for a defense already dealing with a pile of injuries, and it could seriously complicate the Lions’ push for the NFC North title.
Hutchinson now joins a small, unfortunate group of players who have suffered major injuries while celebrating. It’s tempting to say he shouldn’t have jumped, but this was a freak accident. Football is full of moments like that, and there’s no clear person to blame.
Fate may be the word that comes to mind, because Hutchinson’s absence could have a major effect on Detroit’s season. The Lions are still 7-2 and firmly in the playoff picture, with a real chance to win the division. But losing a player of his ability is a serious blow, particularly as the schedule gets tougher.
Hutchinson isn’t easy to replace
Looking only at Hutchinson’s six sacks might make his production seem replaceable. It isn’t. He has been among the NFL’s most disruptive edge rushers this season, even when opponents have regularly sent extra blockers his way. Finishing sacks may not be his biggest strength; creating pressure is.
Through nine games, Hutchinson has recorded 52 pressures and a league-leading 34 quarterback hurries. He combines speed and power exceptionally well, making it difficult for offenses to slow him down with chip blocks. Teams often have to commit extra help just to keep him from getting to the quarterback.
His pressure numbers are remarkable, too. Hutchinson has generated pressure on 14.9% of his 347 pass-rush snaps, with a pass-rush win rate of 27.1%. For comparison, Myles Garrett posted a 29% win rate last season while setting the NFL’s single-season sack record.
Derrick Moore is expected to take Hutchinson’s place in the lineup, but he’s been more of a rotational rusher. Moore’s pressure rate is 10%, and his win rate is considerably lower. Detroit’s pass rush is likely to take a substantial hit, forcing the defense to adjust.
Hutchinson’s work against the run is easy to overlook. His tackle-for-loss numbers aren’t especially eye-catching, partly because teams tend to avoid running toward his side. He has been effective at setting the edge, while Jack Campbell often cleaned up plays inside or on the other side. Campbell is also out, so Detroit has lost two important pieces of that defensive combination.
The schedule is tough
Detroit’s remaining schedule isn’t impossible, but it presents some challenges. Before Hutchinson’s injury, the Lions were projected to win five of these eight games:
- Buccaneers: Win
- Bears: Loss
- Falcons: Win
- Titans: Win
- Vikings: Loss
- Giants: Win
- Bears: Loss
- Packers: Win
Five more wins would have left Detroit at 12-5. Some of those projected victories look less certain now. Tampa Bay has one of the league’s better defenses and could put pressure on Jared Goff. Without Hutchinson to contend with, the Buccaneers may also have an easier time establishing their running game.
Atlanta has struggled, though Bijan Robinson is still a threat. The Falcons and Titans games still look like favorable matchups for Detroit, at least on paper.
The Giants and Packers are harder to call. New York has the edge rushers to trouble Goff, while Green Bay could create more explosive plays if Jordan Love has extra time in the pocket. Those games feel much closer to toss-ups now.
The margins in the NFC North are thin. Four teams are fighting for three playoff spots, and there may not be much room for mistakes down the stretch. Hutchinson’s absence also puts more responsibility on a defense already hit by injuries. Whether anyone can step up enough to make up for the loss remains an open question.
Is this the end for the Lions?
It’s too soon to write off Detroit. The full effect of Hutchinson’s injury won’t be clear right away, though a flat performance—or a loss—against Tampa Bay would be a reason for concern. There’s little doubt this is one of the worst defensive injuries the Lions could have faced, and the timing is rough, coming less than a week after the trade deadline.
For now, the Lions have to figure out what comes next.


