Trick or Trope?

A Halloween decoration available on Amazon is raising concerns among Jewish Americans, who are calling it an “oldest antisemitic smear.”

This life-sized animatronic witch features all the classic eerie elements—sharp claws, a sinister face, and a spellbook.

However, instead of the traditional five-pointed pentacle typically associated with witchcraft, her spellbook prominently displays a Star of David. Critics argue that this fosters harmful stereotypes by suggesting that Jews are sorcerers who cast spells on the world.

In Brooklyn, a woman who unknowingly purchased the $219 decoration was appalled when she realized the Jewish symbolism included. “I’m very upset; this is horrible,” she responded, emphasizing that she doesn’t want to offend anyone and identifying herself as a supporter of Israel and the Jewish community.

She explained that her handyman had set it up without her noticing, leading her to think that reaching out to Amazon might be necessary.

Jewish New Yorkers have expressed their outrage as well.

“Amazon is selling a life-sized witch holding a spell book with the Star of David on it. This reflects one of the oldest antisemitic tropes—associating Jews with witchcraft,” said Moshe Spern, president of the United Jewish Teachers group. He critiqued Amazon for either overlooking this issue or not caring, especially during a time when antisemitic incidents are on the rise in Brooklyn.

Additionally, watchdog group StopAntisemitism highlighted a troubling trend regarding Jewish imagery in everyday items. For instance, they pointed out a rebranded Dr. Evil costume that features a Jewish star on its signature pinky ring.

“With antisemitism on the rise, it’s disturbing to see Jewish symbols included in Halloween costumes. These design choices might seem minor, but they can perpetuate harmful stereotypes and normalize antisemitism,” said Liora Rez, founder of StopAntisemitism, urging Amazon to remove such products immediately.

This incident is part of a larger pattern of seemingly benign novelties facing backlash. Recently, a CVS Barbie was criticized for carrying Nazi imagery in its packaging, sparking a boycott of Mattel.

The Post has reached out to Amazon for a response.