A major legal fight over artificial intelligence is testing a longstanding copyright principle and raising questions about the Trump administration’s approach to AI.
Several media organizations, including The New York Times, are suing OpenAI and Microsoft, alleging that the companies used millions of newspaper articles to train AI systems without permission. The companies argue that using copyrighted material for training is fair use, a legal doctrine that permits some uses without a creator’s consent or payment.
The Justice Department has backed OpenAI’s position in a statement filed with the court, taking a more sweeping view than the administration’s broader policy guidance. Its argument could allow AI companies to use copyrighted works for commercial training with little obligation to seek permission or compensate their creators.
The department says licensing requirements could raise costs for AI developers, make it harder for smaller companies to compete, and weaken U.S. leadership and national security. Those concerns are worth weighing. Still, the brief’s broad interpretation sits uneasily alongside the White House’s AI framework, which recognizes that there are legitimate arguments on both sides of the copyright debate.
Principles adopted by G20 ministers at a recent Commerce Department meeting also describe AI and copyright as complicated legal and policy issues. They recognize copyright’s importance to creators and call for intellectual property protections to remain part of AI policy.
The Justice Department’s position may also overlook how licensing could benefit smaller AI companies. Some startups say that paying for content gives them more dependable access to training material, reduces legal uncertainty, and can improve their models. Companies have also formed to bring copyright holders together and simplify licensing.
Large AI firms, meanwhile, are among the companies best able to pay for copyrighted material. Their participation could help build the licensing markets they say are currently difficult to navigate.
National security concerns would not, by themselves, erase property rights. The Constitution and other laws require compensation when private property is taken for public use, and intellectual property is property too. Allowing companies to use creators’ work without permission or payment would raise questions similar to letting a data center developer take private land without paying its value.
If courts decide that fair use protects AI training in nearly every circumstance, creators could have less reason to produce new work. Copyright protections help writers, artists, and others earn a living from their work, and licensing contributes to an industry that supports more than $1 trillion in U.S. economic activity.
Weaker protections could mean fewer books, articles, research papers, films, and songs made by people. That could eventually leave AI systems with less varied or lower-quality material to learn from, which would hardly benefit anyone.
The administration could instead follow the more measured approach in its own AI framework and leave courts to consider copyright disputes individually, rather than urging a near-universal fair-use exemption.
Congress could also consider the bipartisan CLEAR Act, introduced in February by Sens. Adam Schiff, a California Democrat, and John Curtis, a Utah Republican. The proposal would require AI developers to disclose which copyrighted works were included in the training data for each new generative AI model.
The bill would not decide whether a particular use of copyrighted material counts as fair use. It would, however, give creators a way to find out whether their work was used and consider seeking compensation or other remedies if they believe their rights were infringed.
That kind of targeted change could help enforce copyright in the AI era. Rather than treating licensing as an obstacle to innovation, policymakers could support a system that makes it easier for developers to license material while respecting creators’ rights.
AI innovation matters to America’s future. So does a strong creative sector. Policy should make room for both.






