America’s battle against good sense is also a battle against beauty.

America’s battle against good sense is also a battle against beauty.

“They’re stripping away the very reason they’re there,” Jan told me, describing an academic writing center that had recently said grammar was no longer essential. “They’re taking the whole thing apart. Why? Do they realize what they’re doing?”

Jan, whose name I’ve changed with her permission, booked a coaching session with me. She lives in a strongly progressive part of the country and began working in academia and libraries years ago, before the current ideological shifts took hold.

The writing center’s position went beyond saying grammar was unimportant. It framed standard English grammar as oppressive to Black people, immigrants, people with limited literacy, and others. We talked about the strange contradiction of a writing center treating the basic tools of writing as a form of bondage. Then our conversation turned to appearance.

“They make themselves look ugly on purpose,” Jan said, mentioning unusual hair colors and facial piercings before trailing off. The question hanging between us was simple: why?

Keeping quiet in progressive circles

There’s a connection, I think, between rejecting logic and order and rejecting beauty.

Jan never thought of herself as especially political. For much of her adult life, she considered herself a moderate, somewhat conservative on a few issues but generally liberal. Those views would have been considered liberal in the 1990s or early 2000s. Over the past two decades, though, she’s watched familiar opinions recast as far-right or even fascist.

At work, she now feels a bit like an undercover observer. She’s not yet middle-aged and looks younger than she is. The many earrings along one ear provide a kind of camouflage, she thinks; people assume she shares their radical politics. New acquaintances quickly bring up removing Trump from office or making the country safe again for transgender children.

They don’t seem to consider that Jan might disagree. It’s as if they can’t imagine a reasonable person outside their political circle.

Jan works with information and language, so the erosion of academic and workplace standards troubles her deeply. Students come to her institution to learn, and teaching is part of her job. Yet the institution has become hostile to grammar, the system languages use to organize meaning and make communication possible.

Her expression said it plainly: What is going on?

Ordinary, and harsh

Jan and I aren’t alone in being concerned about the abandonment of shared standards for making sense. That’s a serious problem in itself. Consider American public schools, where phonics instruction was pushed aside for years in favor of whole-language approaches. The most recent figures from the U.S. Department of Education show that only 31% of fourth-graders reached proficiency in reading, down from the results reported in 2019 and 2022.

But there’s a deeper decline that troubles people who are trying, in good faith, to make sense of things. When logic, consistency, and order weaken, beauty often goes with them. You can see it in public spaces: streets in big cities and small towns alike are increasingly littered. In Burlington, Vermont, where I live, parks downtown have had needles and human waste on the grass.

And the ugliness isn’t just about litter. Much of the built environment feels bland, severe, and sometimes actively unpleasant. Some McDonald’s restaurants, once bright and colorful, have been redesigned as gray, fortress-like structures of concrete and sharp angles. Plenty of other fast-food restaurants and shops have followed the same pattern.

People paint over the hardwood in older homes or replace it with pale drywall and dark gray accents that seem to absorb the light.

Cars from different manufacturers have begun to look remarkably alike: rounded, bulky shapes in a narrow range of white, gray, and black.

Even a doorknob in an ordinary home around 1900 often had some detail or character. Compare that with the hardware-store aisles today, where polished surfaces seem to conceal a sea of plain squares and rectangles. Everything has the look of a brushed-steel device.

The style of the 2020s can feel distinctly unfriendly to human beings.

A theater of despair

Why has this happened? I can’t say for certain. Maybe part of the answer is that we’ve lost hope. We don’t trust that the world can be made coherent, or that beauty can lift us up.

The damage caused by chaos and ugliness is easier to recognize. A few years ago, I visited the Bread & Puppet museum in Vermont. It’s associated with a puppet theater company, but the exhibits struck me as something more: a physical expression of bleak ideas.

The puppets and dioramas were grim and unsettling, filled with despair and images of powerful capitalists crushing ordinary workers.

When my friend and I left, we looked at each other and said it felt like stepping through a doorway into hell. This theater company also performs for public-school children in Vermont.

An unsettling spectacle

Last week, a young woman who runs an account called “The War on Beauty” posted a tearful video about modern art she’d seen at a museum. One work showed a kneeling human figure with a long tube resembling feces extending from its backside. In another room, figures that looked like corpses hung from the ceiling.

The visit left her feeling despair. Some people accused her of overreacting. I don’t think she was. I had a similar reaction at the Bread & Puppet museum, and Jan feels something close to it as her workplace discards basic standards while colleagues deliberately cultivate an appearance she finds ugly.

Two stories from Scripture come to mind. When people built a tower in an effort to reach heaven, God confused their languages as a rebuke to their ambition. Today, we seem determined to confuse language ourselves. And like the Israelites making a golden calf, we’ve fashioned an idol—only ours looks more like cheap yellow plastic.

We’re leading ourselves away from what we need. Reason, order, clear communication, and beauty are connected. They aren’t separate concerns, and we risk a great deal when we cast them aside.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News