Justice Barrett Reflects on Charlie Kirk’s Death
Supreme Court Justice Amy Coney Barrett made a poignant statement Thursday night regarding the death of conservative activist Charlie Kirk, highlighting the “grace and strength” exhibited by his wife, Erica, following the tragic incident.
While speaking at the Federalist Society’s annual dinner, Barrett expressed particular admiration for Erica Kirk’s choice to forgive her husband’s murderer. “Targeting poison with poison doesn’t work; it creates more poison,” Barrett noted, urging students to embody Erica’s high road of grace in the face of adversity.
Barrett addressed attendees, including lawyers and law students, seated beside Justice Brett Kavanaugh. She described Erica’s forgiveness as one of the “most moving things,” particularly in response to a question about how conservatives should engage in campus discussions after Charlie Kirk’s assassination during a speech at a Utah university.
“When you observe the toxicity and anger that led to Charlie Kirk’s murder, don’t retreat. Respond with strength and grace,” Barrett encouraged. “You still have a point.” Many students echoed their shock over Kirk’s death, which resonated across campuses and sparked conversations about increasing fears of violence.
Leaders among young conservatives have voiced concerns about their safety and the troubling trend of avoiding controversial speakers which may lead to a chilling effect on free expression.
Yale Federalist Society chapter head David Hauns remarked, “I think it struck a deep chord with all of us. The threat of political violence, especially against conservatives in law schools and on college campuses, is very concerning.” This sentiment was echoed by Kavanaugh, who pointed to a broader environment rife with threats to judges and politicians from all sides, as indicated by a recent case where an individual received an eight-year sentence for attempting to assassinate him.
Kavanaugh shared how he draws inspiration from the Catholic hymn “Fear Not,” emphasizing the importance of standing firm for one’s beliefs despite potential backlash. “Don’t be afraid to stand up for your principles, even when criticized,” he advised, reflecting on the challenges faced throughout his career.
This conversation took place during the Federalist Society’s Antonin Scalia Memorial Dinner, moderated by U.S. District Judge Trevor McFadden, with other prominent attendees including Samuel Alito and Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche.
