Biden discusses the infamous “we beat Medicare” debate moment in his new memoir

Biden discusses the infamous “we beat Medicare” debate moment in his new memoir

In his memoir, Promise Me, America, released Tuesday, former President Joe Biden revisits his June 2024 debate against Donald Trump and the moment he mistakenly said, “We beat Medicare.” He writes that the slip became proof, in the eyes of many, that he was too old for the job.

Biden says he lost his train of thought while answering a question about the deficit. As the clock ran down, he rushed to finish and said, “We finally beat Medicare,” when he meant, “We finally beat Big Pharma.” He was referring to the Inflation Reduction Act, which gave Medicare the ability to negotiate lower drug prices.

He calls the policy a major achievement of his administration, but says the debate blunder overshadowed it. What he thought might have been a strong moment instead became a defining example of concerns about his age, he writes.

Biden also accuses Trump of making repeated false claims during the debate. Still, he says, the attention afterward focused on his own answers and performance. He knew the debate had gone poorly, but thought he would get another chance to face Trump before the election.

Democratic leaders and political commentators, Biden writes, treated the performance as fatal to his campaign. He argues that polling right after the debate did not show an immediate collapse, and that it took weeks of negative coverage for his numbers to fall. In his view, the political narrative mattered more than the early data: the prevailing belief was that he had lost and could not recover.

Biden points to other presidents who struggled in their first reelection debates. He recalls that his own 2012 debate with Republican vice presidential candidate Paul Ryan took on extra importance after Barack Obama’s poor showing against Mitt Romney. He also cites Ronald Reagan’s debate against Walter Mondale and George W. Bush’s and Obama’s debate performances as examples of incumbents who had difficult nights.

Incumbent presidents, Biden writes, are often preoccupied with governing rather than campaigning. He says the key difference in 2024 was that other presidents had another debate in which to recover, while he did not.

In an interview about the memoir, Biden said he did not consider his debate performance especially consequential. He noted that he expected another debate, which never happened. In the book, he says the evening felt wrong from the beginning and describes the episode as a turning point in a campaign he eventually left after weeks of pressure from Democrats.

Former first lady Jill Biden said in a May interview that she thought her husband might be having a stroke during the debate.

Costas Panagopoulos, a political science professor at Northeastern University, said Biden was right that other presidents had performed badly in debates and later had a chance to recover. But, Panagopoulos added, Biden’s performance reinforced existing doubts about whether his age left him prepared to serve, concerns that had surfaced across party lines well before the debate.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News