Cleveland Browns’ Quarterback Dilemma Under Todd Monken

Todd Monken, now the head coach of the Cleveland Browns, has a significant decision to make regarding his starting quarterback for the upcoming season. With three candidates at his disposal, the choice isn’t straightforward.

Deshaun Watson, last season’s anticipated starter, was sidelined due to injuries. Meanwhile, the Browns added Dillon Gabriel, a third-round pick in 2025, along with Shedure Sanders, who took the reins as the starting quarterback towards the end of the previous season.

Monken is observing how each candidate will perform. In particular, the spotlight is on Sanders, who led the team in the last seven games of 2025. There’s a sense of anticipation surrounding whether he will become Monken’s chosen starter.

During the NFL Scouting Combine, Monken addressed the quarterback situation, specifically about Sanders potentially leading the team. “We’re seeing elite playmaking ability,” he mentioned. “He showed it in college and last season, and while there’s room for growth, that’s something every rookie experiences. I’m eager to work with all our quarterbacks.”

Sanders recorded a 3-4 record in his starts, while Gabriel struggled with a 1-5 performance as a substitute for Joe Flacco, who was traded to the Bengals due to Joe Burrow’s injury.

Interestingly, the Ravens, where Monken previously served as offensive coordinator, were keen on drafting Sanders to support Lamar Jackson. However, Sanders expressed a desire to join a team where he could compete for the starting position.

Following a surprising draft drop, the Browns selected Sanders in the fifth round. In contrast, Watson’s tenure has been marked by challenges, being on the last year of a fully guaranteed $250 million contract. Despite previously being a Pro Bowl selection, he has only played 17 games since joining Cleveland, partly due to injuries.

Yet, Monken maintains that any player demonstrating elite potential deserves another chance. “You should always give players the benefit of the doubt, hoping to bring out their best,” he stated. “That’s my approach with every player.”

Watson’s record with the Browns presents a mixed bag, at 9-10, including a disappointing 1-6 in 2024 before an Achilles injury cut his season short. As for Sanders, he posted 1,400 yards, with seven touchdowns and ten interceptions during his brief tenure, culminating in his selection for the Pro Bowl.