Claims that Duke is overrated will continue in college basketball unless it fixes these problems.

Claims that Duke is overrated will continue in college basketball unless it fixes these problems.

As the 2026–27 men’s college basketball season approached, Duke was already being treated as the team to beat. Preseason rankings put the Blue Devils at No. 1, and some observers suggested even their bench could be among the nation’s best. Incoming freshman Joaquim Boumtje Boumtje, just 17, was widely touted as a potential top player in the sport, despite being too young to enter the NBA Draft until 2028.

Jon Scheyer was so confident in the team that he reportedly passed on a chance to coach Cooper Flagg and the Dallas Mavericks. Before the season, he said he believed Duke would win a national championship soon.

Of course, championships aren’t won in the fall. Duke faced plenty of competition, and there were reasons to wonder whether this group would have the same advantages as the teams before it. Those concerns became harder to ignore last week, when Michigan State controlled the game for 40 minutes and handed Duke a 79–73 loss. The final margin made it look closer than it was.

The Spartans set the tone from the opening tip, and Duke never found a convincing response. Jeremy Fears Jr. outplayed the Blue Devils’ guards, Duke’s perimeter shooting looked shaky, and Boumtje Boumtje struggled to make an impact. After having the best player on the floor in recent seasons with Cooper Flagg and Cameron Boozer, Duke suddenly looked more like a collection of good players without a clear star to take over.

A comfortable win over SIU-Edwardsville in the next game did little to erase the questions. Duke still has some clear issues to work through, especially with expectations so high that anything short of a Final Four could be seen as a letdown.

Duke needs to find the right way to use Boumtje Boumtje

I was caught up in the Boumtje Boumtje excitement after watching his strong performance at the FIBA U19 World Cup over the summer. I thought he might be the best NBA prospect in the world, though I wasn’t sure he would immediately be a major college player. That’s why I left him off my preseason list of the sport’s top 20 players. His long-term potential is enormous, but right now he’s raising questions as much as answering them.

Duke lists the freshman at 7-foot-2 and 250 pounds. I’d be a little surprised if the height holds up under an actual measurement, but there’s no question he’s huge. The Blue Devils have started him at power forward alongside traditional center Patrick Ngongba. The thinking is that Boumtje Boumtje’s excellent three-point shooting can provide enough spacing to make a two-big lineup work. The Michigan State game, though, showed some of the drawbacks.

He looked too slow to defend the opposing wings who often play power forward in college basketball. At times against Michigan State, he seemed almost stuck in place. On offense, he mostly waited in the corner and rarely became part of the main action. Even going after offensive rebounds could put him in a difficult position: he then had to hurry back and defend a player with a speed advantage.

I wasn’t convinced by the Ngongba–Boumtje Boumtje pairing. It looked limited off the dribble and slow at both ends. I also didn’t see Duke try Boumtje Boumtje as the lone big, even when Ngongba sat; Drew Scharnowski came in beside him instead.

One straightforward adjustment would be to stagger their minutes. That could give each big more speed and playmaking around him for stretches. Boumtje Boumtje might be vulnerable defensively at center, but his shooting and spacing could create real problems for opponents at the other end. He may also be able to attack slower centers off the dribble, while his passing remains an underused part of his game.

Duke should involve him more in pick-and-pop plays, where he can shoot over a big who is slow to close out or drive past one who rushes at him. He could also borrow a little from Karl-Anthony Towns, the closest professional comparison I see: spend more time operating in the post and take a more active role in the offense. Right now, he too often feels like a safety valve rather than a central piece.

Boumtje Boumtje hasn’t made an immediate impact like UCLA forward Nikola Kusturica, another leading candidate for the top pick in the 2028 NBA Draft. That’s not necessarily a problem. The talent is obvious; Duke needs to figure out how best to use it.

Duke’s guards may be an average group

Many national champions over the past 20 years have been led by an elite point guard. After watching Duke’s backcourt struggle against Fears, it’s fair to ask whether the Blue Devils have anyone who can fill that role.

They do have plenty of guards, with a mix of experience and strengths. The group includes sophomore Cayden Boozer, seniors Caleb Foster and Wisconsin transfer John Blackwell, and freshman Deron Rippey Jr. Blackwell is the best shooter, Rippey the most explosive athlete, and Boozer looks like the best passer. Foster is the biggest and may be the most versatile. But it’s not yet clear that any of them can consistently take charge and create a shot against a top defense in a big moment.

Opponents are likely to keep going under screens against Boozer until he proves he can make outside shots. That can crowd the driving and cutting lanes for everyone else. Blackwell can score from the midrange or beyond the arc, but his college career has included nearly as many turnovers as assists, and he doesn’t have the playmaking vision of a top lead guard. Foster may spend much of the season coming off the bench, while Rippey’s speed can put pressure on defenses but his feel for the game still needs to develop.

For now, Duke’s best shot creators may be its big men, Ngongba and Boumtje Boumtje. The season is long, and the Blue Devils have enough talent among their guards that someone could emerge as the primary option. They just haven’t found that player yet.

Can Duke shoot well enough?

Duke has struggled from three-point range in three of its first four games. Several players could, in theory, make defenses pay from outside, but there aren’t many whom opponents seem genuinely worried about.

The Blue Devils are shooting 30.4 percent from three, which ranks 232nd nationally. They went 4-for-22 against Army, 9-for-29 against SIU-Edwardsville and 7-for-29 against Michigan State. Three-pointers account for 41.3 percent of their field-goal attempts, a rate that sounds high but ranks only 182nd in the country.

A leap from sophomore wing Dame Sarr would help. His defense and athleticism make him important to the rotation, and he made 32.3 percent of 133 three-point attempts as a freshman. He has started this season cold, but there’s room for him to improve. Blackwell also needs to keep shooting like he did last year, when he jumped from 32.2 percent on 180 attempts as a Wisconsin sophomore to 39 percent on 247 attempts as a junior.

Boumtje Boumtje could be another major factor. If Duke finds the right role for him, he has the potential to become one of the country’s most dangerous shooting big men.

Duke should be very good, but it may need to be great to meet expectations

Scheyer showed his ability as a coach when he led a No. 4 seed to the Elite Eight in 2024. The next season, Duke reached the Final Four, though the result still felt disappointing given the team’s talent, including three lottery picks: Flagg, Kon Knueppel and Khaman Maluach. Last season, the Blue Devils had a strong chance to win it all behind Cameron Boozer, but UConn ended their run in the Elite Eight on Braylon Mullins’ buzzer-beater.

This year’s team was expected to rank among the nation’s best, alongside Florida, Illinois and UConn. Michigan State was also a preseason top-five team, and on a neutral court the Spartans looked clearly stronger. Early-season games like the Champions Classic, and Duke’s upcoming matchup with Illinois, offer a chance to measure up against elite competition and learn from it. One thing is already apparent: Duke has plenty of work ahead.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News