Carly Pearce Discusses Faith and Identity in Her Music

Carly Pearce recently reflected on her upbringing and the interplay between faith and identity that shaped her as an artist. In an interview, the 35-year-old singer, known for her duet “If I Don’t Leave, I’m Gonna Stay” with Riley Green, explored the themes in her song “Church Girl.”

This particular track addresses the struggles of a young woman who believes in God yet feels burdened by guilt and judgment from those around her for not adhering strictly to traditional Christian values. Pearce, raised in a devout family in rural Kentucky, finds these themes particularly relatable.

“I think the reason this song resonates with me is that, as a Southern woman of faith, it touches on childhood issues like sexual shame and the guilt many of us endure while trying to lead a Christ-like life,” she shared.

Having faced her own challenges in the public eye, including a divorce, Pearce expressed her desire for the song to serve as an anthem for others on their personal journeys. “I want people to feel seen and valued,” she added.

Pearce and fellow country artist Michael Ray married in October 2019 but split just eight months later. She has been open about the emotional toll of that period, saying, “I was embarrassed and heartbroken… it was tough.” In a previous interview, she admitted feeling guilty over her breakup.

When she spoke to People magazine earlier this year, Pearce described how “Church Girl” provided comfort during her divorce. “It’s like I was letting God down with this marriage,” she recalled, voicing her inner conflict.

She emphasized that it’s important to tell people struggling with their faith that they are not alone. Reflecting on her faith’s role in bolstering her through the ups and downs of her career, Pearce stated, “My faith keeps me grounded in this turbulent industry.”

“Church Girl” was released on January 23rd and will feature on her upcoming fifth studio album, which she described as a return to her Kentucky and Appalachian roots.

Pearce reminisced about her childhood in Kentucky, which fostered her love for music. “I had the best family and grandparents who introduced me to traditional country and bluegrass genres,” she shared, detailing her early experiences performing with a bluegrass band.

This upbringing continues to guide her music, as she aspires to resonate with listeners through genuine artistry. “I want to create songs that endure,” she emphasized, acknowledging her roots remain an essential part of who she is.

Pearce’s new duet with Green exhibits a complex relationship dynamic. In the song, they explore themes of knowing a relationship is unsuitable yet feeling irresistibly drawn to each other. She described the process of crafting the song as tapping into their personal experiences, with a sense of relatability for anyone who has felt similarly.

As for her future, Pearce expressed enthusiasm for entering a new chapter, feeling the healthiest and happiest she has been. “It’s as if all these experiences have prepared me for this moment,” she said, affirming her resilience through it all.