There is no longer a single common understanding of justice in America. There are now two Americas, each applying different justice depending on who you are and where you live. America, ruled by common sense and personal courage, celebrates heroes who stand up to protect others. The other, driven by political objectives and corrupt institutions, punishes the bold actions of the same heroes.
Nowhere is this stark divide clearer than in the trial of Marine Daniel Penny in New York City this week, which drew strong reactions from both sides across the divided judicial lines.
If we leave this unchecked, we will accept a world where heroes are treated as criminals and laws are weapons of ideological warfare.
Last year, Penny was riding the subway when Jordan Neely, a man reportedly suffering from severe mental illness and a drug addict, began threatening passengers, saying, “I'm going to kill you all.” . The fear inside the subway car was palpable, but no one moved. That is, no one was there until Penny did what she had to do. He took action to protect innocent lives.
In America, as many of us once believed, Penny's reaction will be hailed as heroic. His actions reflected the courage of Flight 93's Todd Beamer on September 11, 2001, who rallied others with the words “Let's roll” to prevent further tragedies. But in New York, courage no longer seems to matter. There, the system turns heroes into villains.
Penny uses a chokehold to subdue Neely, not intending to kill him, but rather restrain him. Tragically, Neely passed away. Penny felt remorseful and told police she never meant to hurt anyone. However, Penny was found not to have protected others from a clear and present threat and was tried for manslaughter.
In Alvin Bragg's New York, justice succumbs to ideology. The Manhattan district attorney has spent his career using the law as a weapon, selectively prosecuting people who don't align with his case. He's the same prosecutor who twisted legal precedent to go after Donald Trump on business charges no one had ever faced before. Then he turned to Daniel Penny.
The jury may have acquitted Penny, but what happened this week in New York City is not justice. When the rule of law changes based on the identity of the defendant or the political motives of the prosecutor, we no longer live in a free country. We live in a state where justice is a game and ordinary Americans are its pawns.
The System Broke Jordan Neely
It's worth asking where activists like Alvin Bragg were when Neely was languishing on the streets. Jordan Neely was a tragic man who suffered from mental illness and had over 40 arrests, including for violent assault. The system failed him long before he got on that subway. But rather than face that uncomfortable truth, Mr. Bragg's office decided to target the man who intervened to prevent the tragedy.
This is not about justice. It's a question of power. It's about advancing the narrative that race and identity are more important than truth and common sense.
It's time for change
The Daniel Penny case and similar cases are sounding alarm bells. We cannot allow corrupt institutions to punish those who act to protect life and liberty. Americans must demand an end to politically driven prosecutions, hold prosecutors like Alvin Bragg accountable, and uphold the principle that true justice is blind, consistent, and impartial.
If we leave this unchecked, we will accept a world where heroes are treated as criminals and laws are weapons of ideological warfare. It's time to choose which America you want to live in.
I want more glenn beck?Get Glenn's free email newsletter Get his latest insights, top stories, show prep and more delivered to your inbox.
