New York’s Political Landscape: A Shift in Voter Sentiment

During dinner at St. Mark’s Place on Sunday night, while munching on fried chickpeas, my friend Ines quipped, “It’s Mandani’s New York.” Quite the statement for anyone opposed to communism, and yet—she might actually be onto something.

Now, Ines leans pretty conservative, making me seem like a radical by comparison. She’s a prominent voice in conservative circles but told me, “I’m still undecided about my vote. Maybe Sliwa, maybe Cuomo—I’m just not sure yet.”

And she isn’t alone in feeling this way. Recently, in areas of New York that lean red or purple, like Staten Island and Bay Ridge, conservative voters are expressing skepticism. They claim that neither independent candidate Curtis Sliwa nor former Governor Andrew Cuomo has made a compelling case for their support.

“Really? Am I supposed to vote for Andrew Freakin’ Cuomo?” an elder from St. George on Staten Island asked me. I nodded. He might have his reservations about democratic socialists like Zoran Mandani, but he’s been critical of Cuomo for over a decade now.

One resident at a bagel shop in Bay Ridge voiced a sentiment shared by many: “What’s the difference between Mr. Cuomo and Mr. Mamdani?”

In classic New York style, these voters are practically pleading with Cuomo to provide some rationale for their support, wanting to overlook his past actions during the pandemic, his resignation, and his controversial policies like cash bail and statements suggesting certain people have no place in New York.

Yet, Cuomo seems unable to muster the necessary appeal, offering little to sway voters towards him over Curtis Sliwa, whom they generally like and may even know personally.

Currently, Cuomo could capitalize on the situation. He might consider supporting Republican Maud Maron in her fight against Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg, whose policies many see as fueling widespread disorder. If Cuomo aligns with Bragg, it could alienate a segment of right-wing voters.

Cuomo could also commit to addressing New York’s sanctuary city status. The current mayor, Eric Adams, has shown frustration with the Biden administration’s immigration policies. There’s a chance Cuomo could take a stand against the administration’s approach.

Promises to work with, rather than against, federal efforts to manage illegal immigration could potentially draw in conservative votes as well.

Time is of the essence for Andrew Cuomo; he essentially has until Tuesday morning to make a move—something to convince Ines and others why he deserves their vote.

Karol Markowitz, a columnist and former Brooklyn resident, aptly noted that “Mr. Cuomo needs to humble himself.” Conservative voters in New York are not inclined to forgive his past as governor, nor do they necessarily seek an apology.

As the hours tick by, Gotham’s conservative voters are urging Andrew Cuomo, “Please, just give us something to believe in.” If he fails to pivot towards these voters, not only could he lose on Tuesday, but he may also face embarrassment. I can’t say for certain, but I wouldn’t be surprised if he ends up in third place.

This presents a crucial moment for Cuomo’s campaign and hints at a larger issue within the city. He lost the primary election and suggested forming coalitions, but has yet to offer any real assurances, like addressing the no-cash bail policy.

The call is clear: Andrew, it’s time to provide conservative voters with what they want.