Carson Benge struggled early in his major league career, hitting just .108 in his first 11 games while playing for a team like the Mets, known for their high expectations. They were looking for a quick turnaround after last year’s disappointing season, and you’d think they might be tempted to make a change. But, David Stearns, the president of baseball operations, firmly stated that Benge’s spot on the team isn’t in jeopardy.
“We’re going to be patient,” Stearns commented on Friday. “Carson is part of this team, and I believe he can contribute to our success this year.”
One of Benge’s strengths is his versatility; he brings much more than just batting. While he’s got defensive skills, his abilities as a base runner also add value. This could give him some breathing room while he figures out his batting at the major league level.
As an outfielder with an impressive arm, Benge has showcased his speed and has already stolen four bases. Yet, the Mets hoped to see more from his bat when they gave him the starting role on opening day.
But the adjustment to facing top-tier pitching has been evident. After a brief stint in the minors, including 24 games with Triple-A Syracuse, he made his major league debut last year. His early performance this season recorded four hits in 37 at-bats: one home run, five walks, and 12 strikeouts. Last year, he displayed good discipline with a strikeout rate around 17.7 percent, but that rate has now soared to 28.6 percent.
“We’ve seen some great at-bats from him,” Stearns acknowledged. “At times, he gets a bit too eager, perhaps, and tries to do too much. But we believe he’s a strong athlete and a great player. The key for him, like many rookies, is figuring out how to navigate the pressures of the big leagues.”
Benge’s early difficulties have also raised questions about the Mets’ overall defense. Stearns had previously emphasized the need for improvement, even considering moving key players like Pete Alonso in free agency and trading others. While the Mets have become more athletic this season, they’ve placed some players in unfamiliar roles, which has led to mixed results.
Despite a couple of shaky moments in the field, the overall defensive performance has been rated between average and elite based on advanced metrics.
“We have a solid defense,” Stearns remarked. “It involves players adapting to different positions, which is something we’ve had to embrace.”
Manaea’s Situation
Stearns believes there’s a good chance Sean Manaea will return to the rotation soon. After being shifted to a long relief role, Manaea is stuck behind others as the Mets prioritize a fifth starting pitcher. The Mets are hopeful he can regain his speed; however, they recognize that a fully healthy rotation is hard to come by.
“Historically, a lot of starters are needed throughout the season,” Stearns said. “I really think Sean will be making a lot of starts for us this year, as he is fully capable of performing.”
Currently, the only pitcher struggling in the rotation is David Peterson, but Stearns remains optimistic about him, stating he believes Peterson will get through this rough patch.
Potential Reinforcements
As AJ Minter begins his rehab, the minor leagues also house two veterans, relievers Craig Kimbrel and Tommy Pham, who are pushing to make a return to the big leagues. Kimbrel hasn’t left camp and threw a shutout, including a strikeout in an outing against Low-A St. Lucie. Meanwhile, Pham signed a minor league contract last week and is set to begin play with St. Lucie before moving to Syracuse.
If Pham can find his groove at the plate, he might be able to serve as a valuable piece for the team, possibly as a platoon outfielder. But, of course, performance will dictate their roles.
“We’re excited to have him in the organization,” Stearns mentioned. “Once he’s ready, we’ll assess where we stand.”
