Democratic judge criticized for releasing violent offenders calls bail law a direct attack on rights

Democratic judge criticized for releasing violent offenders calls bail law a direct attack on rights

Alabama Circuit Judge David Carpenter, a Democrat facing questions over past rulings involving violent offenders, has criticized a state law that lets courts deny bail to people charged with certain serious crimes.

Carpenter says Alabama’s Aniah’s Law conflicts with constitutional protections. In his view, defendants should not be jailed indefinitely simply because they have been charged, given the presumption that they are innocent until proven guilty.

In a social media post, he compared concerns about license plate readers, including Flock cameras, with what he sees as a lack of public concern about laws that expand pretrial detention.

Carpenter argued that people who view cameras recording license plates on public roads as government overreach should also question laws that allow the government to keep someone in jail indefinitely based only on a criminal charge.

He said laws like Aniah’s Law undermine the presumption of innocence, adding that the reaction to expanded detention powers has been far less intense than the response to surveillance cameras.

Aniah’s Law was first passed in 2022. This year, Alabama voters approved a constitutional amendment extending it to cover additional offenses, including attempted murder, soliciting or conspiring to commit murder, and firing a gun or explosives into an occupied home, building or vehicle.

“We are all one accusation away from being a criminal defendant,” Carpenter wrote on Facebook.

Carpenter’s past decisions have drawn controversy. Local news reports say he once described himself online as a “far left, liberal, progressive, democratic socialist.”

In April 2023, he approved a plea deal for Damien McDaniel, who had been arrested in 2019 after allegedly shooting two people in a car when he was 17. After McDaniel was released, he was accused of carrying out a 14-month shooting spree in Alabama that left 18 people dead and more than 30 injured.

Carpenter also granted bond to Raukeem Cunningham in a case involving the 2022 fatal shooting of a teenage girl, according to local reports. While out on bond, Cunningham was arrested and charged in connection with the fatal shootings of three people at a Bessemer gas station in 2024. His earlier bond was then revoked.

Reports also say Carpenter dismissed a 2015 rape charge against Fredrick Terrenda Hampton in 2019. Two days later, Hampton met Paighton Houston, who subsequently disappeared. Her body was later found buried behind a home; she had died from an accidental overdose.

Hampton pleaded guilty to abusing a corpse in connection with Houston’s death. Carpenter sentenced him to 20 years, with three years to be served in custody, according to local reports.

Houston’s mother later asked Alabama Attorney General Steve Marshall to investigate Carpenter’s decision to release Hampton, whom critics described as a repeat sex offender.

During his judicial campaign, Carpenter said he wanted to reform Alabama’s criminal justice system. He also said he would seek to reduce repeat offending while addressing the state’s costly prison overcrowding.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News