Derek Jeter criticized for not attending Yankees Old-Timers’ Day: Boomer Esiason

The Yankees’ Old Timers Day and Jeter’s Absence

This August, the Yankees will honor their 2000 World Series team during Old Timers Day, but notable members, like Derek Jeter, won’t be attending.

His absence has stirred up discussions on WFAN, particularly between Boomer Esiason and Gregg Giannotti.

“It’s a bit insulting… I think he should be there, he should be part of it,” Esiason remarked on “Boomer and Gio” on Tuesday. “It seems to me elitist.”

Although over 30 former Yankees will participate, the iconic “Captain” is notably missing.

“Derek Jeter told fans that at this age, he didn’t want to see himself hit again,” said Giannotti, referring to Jeter’s reasoning.

Yet, this game has been a tradition for nearly 80 years, and all participating players are, well, older. Esiason highlighted that iconic figures like Mickey Mantle and Joe DiMaggio used to play together during these events, questioning why Jeter can’t do the same.

Jeter, now 51, last played in 2014 and has a decorated career with 14 All-Star selections, five World Series championships, and several individual awards. While he certainly isn’t in the same shape he was during his playing days, Giannotti argued that Jeter, in particular, wouldn’t embarrass himself by showing up.

“I think he’s in great condition. Some of these others aren’t,” Giannotti stated. “He’s not going to look bad.”

Moreover, it’s not just the fact that Jeter isn’t playing; he’s not attending any festivities. “You don’t have to wear a uniform if you just show up,” Giannotti added.

While Giannotti tried to make sense of Jeter’s decision, Esiason kept returning to his feelings about Jeter’s stance. “For me, I think he was the captain. He was a man who was beloved by fans, and it’s still the day,” he expressed. “I just feel it’s a bit elitist.”