On April 21, 1980, 26-year-old Rosie Ruiz crossed the Boston Marathon finish line in 2 hours, 31 minutes and 56 seconds, then the third-fastest time ever recorded by a woman. Quite a feat, especially for someone who apparently hadn’t run the race.
Ruiz had posted a far slower time at the 1979 New York City Marathon, yet looked unusually fresh after supposedly completing 26.2 miles in Boston. Jacqueline Gareau and Patti Lyons, who had been among the women leading the race, didn’t recall seeing her on the course. Neither, it seemed, did many other people. Officials eventually concluded that Ruiz had joined the race about a mile from the finish. Eight days later, she was stripped of her title. Investigators also found that she had taken the subway during the New York race. Perhaps mass transit was part of her training plan.
Ruiz continued to insist she had run the full course and refused to give up her medal. A quarter-century later, Gareau returned to Boston and finally crossed the finish line first, as she should have in 1980. Justice took its time getting there.
And that brings us, inevitably, to politics. It would be a shame to leave a story about a questionable finish at the finish line.
Republicans still bristle over Joe Biden’s 2020 win, particularly since he campaigned from his basement and went on to receive more than 81 million votes. In Wisconsin, between 3:26 and 3:44 a.m., the Associated Press tally added 149,520 votes for Biden and 31,803 for Trump. To anyone watching the numbers change on television, it might have looked like somebody had taken the subway straight to the finish.
There was, though, a documented explanation: Milwaukee and other communities reported large batches of absentee ballots at once. The votes were counted when they were reported, not discovered in a bag under a train seat. The sudden change in Wisconsin’s tally may have frustrated people politically, but by itself it wasn’t proof of fraud.
Now the 2026 midterms have brought a fresh set of winners who seemed to come out of nowhere.
In Texas, James Talarico defeated Ken Paxton, becoming the first Democrat elected to the Senate seat in decades. Talarico missed nearly two weeks of campaigning after saying he had the flu, which naturally prompted speculation. His campaign released security-camera images that appeared to show him at home. Apparently, a candidate can spend days in bed and still wake up a senator-elect.
Michigan State Senator Sean McCann also scored an upset, defeating longtime Republican Rep. Bill Huizenga in a district Republicans had held for years. Huizenga was ahead by nearly 10,000 votes; two hours later, McCann led by 1,305. No subway ticket has turned up, but there were probably plenty of stunned Republicans.
North Carolina offered another reminder that conventional wisdom doesn’t always predict the result. LaKesha Womack defeated Republican incumbent Tim Moore in the 14th Congressional District. October fundraising reports showed Moore had raised more than $2 million, compared with roughly $59,000 for Womack. If campaign money decided elections, Moore could have been handed the winner’s wreath before the race began.
Then there’s Iowa’s Eric Armstrong, who suspended his campaign in September because of health problems. His name stayed on the ballot, and he beat Republican Keith Jones by 865 votes. Imagine stepping away from the race, heading home, and finding out voters carried you over the finish line anyway. Ruiz might have appreciated that ending.
Arizona’s Sebastian “Seb” Matta, a 19-year-old who graduated from high school in 2025, defeated former Republican state Sen. Jeff Dial to become Maricopa County clerk of the Superior Court. It’s not exactly a job spent collecting permission slips. Matta will oversee a major court-records operation with 670 employees. That should make for an unusual résumé.
Massachusetts elected another 19-year-old, Daniel Darris-O’Connor, who defeated Republican state Rep. Marc Lombardo, an eight-term incumbent, in a Billerica race. When Lombardo first took office, his challenger was still making the transition from diapers to training pants.
O’Connor will soon serve in the legislature of a state with more than four centuries of colonial history, a role in the American Revolution, the country’s first college — and the annual race that made Ruiz infamous.
A sick candidate, another who stopped campaigning, a dramatically underfunded challenger, and two teenagers: the 2026 elections delivered enough surprises to make political consultants reconsider their forecasts. But none of those facts, on its own, suggests cheating. Ruiz skipped the race; these candidates appeared on the ballot and won votes. That distinction matters.
Still, Democrats recorded a claimed 23.4% increase in presidential votes in the unusual 2020 election. After their strong showing against Trump in the 2026 midterms, preliminary figures now point to a 25.2% increase in Democratic votes for the House. One could joke that liberal Democratic women are embracing Sharia, or that Ruiz might have made a career as a Democratic political consultant. Her death in 2019, apparently, wouldn’t get in the way of the punchline.
Ruiz kept insisting she had won, even after officials disqualified her, and she wouldn’t surrender her medal. Here we are in 2026, still turning the subway ride to the finish line into a political metaphor.
The hanging chads are behind us. In the coming days, as election results are reviewed and witnesses speak up, Americans may get a clearer picture of how Democrats managed to turn a historically red map blue. Then again, perhaps the comparison to Rosie Ruiz says more about the people making it than about the candidates who won.






