While sequels are common in Hollywood, director Andy Irwin finds the idea challenging—especially when it comes to convincing himself about creating one.
As chief creative officer at Kingdom Story Company, known for faith-centered films like Jesus Revolution, The Greatest Christmas Pageant Ever, and An Unsung Hero, Irwin has plenty to consider. His company also produced I Can Only Imagine, the acclaimed 2018 film that focused on Bart Millard of Mercy Me and his journey reconciling with his abusive father.
So, when a sequel to I Can Only Imagine was proposed, Irwin wasn’t exactly thrilled. “It was daunting,” he shared, expressing his fears of potentially damaging the original’s legacy. “I worried it might feel forced or gimmicky. My skepticism was real.”
However, through discussions with his team, they managed to persuade him. The sequel, which opens in theaters this weekend, follows Millard years later as he grapples with fatherhood and increasing tensions with his teenage son.
John Michael Finley reprises his role as Millard, while Trace Adkins returns as the band’s manager, Scott Brickell. Dennis Quaid is featured in a flashback, and Irwin co-directed alongside Brent McCorkle.
This film marks Kingdom Story’s first sequel.
Irwin elaborated on the film’s theme, exploring the aftermath of achieving what one desires. “What happens when that joy is short-lived?” he reflected. “It’s a heartfelt message of hope.”
The narrative shifts when Tim Timmons, a bright and optimistic musician, joins the Mercy Me tour. Timmons represents a stark contrast to the more reserved Millard, who is struggling with his happiness. Millard discovers that Timmons’ positivity is genuine, stemming from his battle with terminal cancer. Milo Ventimiglia plays Timmons.
Irwin describes Timmons as the story’s catalyst. “Tim’s journey is quite remarkable,” he noted. “Every day, he marks an ‘X’ on his wrist with a Sharpie, grateful for another day.”
Irwin believes this sequel will surprise audiences, stating that its core message revolves around gratitude. “It’s about Bart navigating his role as a father, realizing he feels unprepared since his own father never taught him the ropes. Ultimately, it leads to a message that transcends simple hope—it’s rooted in hard-earned gratitude. It’s not always easy to come by.”
I Can Only Imagine 2 has a PG rating due to its subject matter and some language.
Related articles
“I Can Only Imagine 2” trailer released: “It’s a beautiful story,” says the director
Photo courtesy: ©Kingdom Story
First publication date is February 17, 2026.
