DC's first openly gay federal judge on Tuesday attempted to codify the conditions of service for trans service members in the US military, attempting to determine the extent of potential harm to transgender service members. The Trump administration has been burned down.
At issue, a January 27 executive order signed by President Donald Trump, in which the Department of Defense updated its guidance on “transporting medical standards for military service,” and said, “contradicting military preparations.” They demand that the guidance be revoked.
US District Judge Ana Reyes ordered, demanding that he know whether it is a “transgender ban” and whether it is a “ideological” government position in transgender. He raised severe doubts about the Trump administration.
This month, civil rights groups pleaded to block the order on behalf of six transgender U.S. service members, claiming the order is discriminatory and unconstitutional. They argued that it threatened US national security and years of training and financial investment by the Department of Defense.
Judges denies Democratic-led efforts to block Doge access, citing the lack of proven harm
E. Barrett Prettyman Courthouse will be seen after Donald Trump's arrest on August 3, 2023 in Washington, DC (Sha Hanting/China News Service/VCG Getty Images)
Tuesday's court hearing focused primarily on the extent to which degree, and extent, the order could harm trans service members. Trump has directed that “radical gender ideology” be banned from all military wings, but the executive order details how the Pentagon should do this, and questions and concerns from plaintiffs and judges urged.
Biden's appointee Reyes spent much of Tuesday's hearing to see how the order will be implemented, transgender service members designated in the lawsuit will be removed from the role or separated from the unit. I asked if it was.
Litigation Tracker: New Resistance to Fight Trump's Second Term through the Onslaught of Lawsuits for EOS
US Secretary of Defense Pete Hegses (Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images)
“The greatest combat forces world history has ever seen are somehow affected by less than 1% of soldiers using different pronouns than others want to call them. Can you agree that there is none?”
At another point in the hearing, she was asked to find an appointed officer with the Department of Justice to board the declarant or stand and tell the court that she was hurt by the use of a transgender military member's pronoun. I tried to do it.
“I'll get a box of cigars,” Reyes told Lynch.
“We have to use pronouns on thousands, so if we can find someone who says we're not very prepared… we have that.”
Doge won a big court victory and allowed access data at three federal agencies
pentagon (Daniel Slim/AFP via Getty Images)
Lynch pointed out in response to the administration waiting for further guidance on the terms of the transgender executive order. This determines the impact on personnel, including the six transgender plaintiffs appointed in the case.
The answer did little to ease Reyes' concerns. He told Lynch the government must notify the court by Wednesday. Orders whether they can guarantee that the appointed service members will not be excluded from the military role or will not face discrimination as a direct result of enforcement.
If they did not do that, the court said it would meet again Friday and consider the plaintiff's request for a temporary restraining order.
Beyond the facts of the case, Reyes did little to hide his dissatisfaction with the order itself.
At one point during the hearing, she hypothesized to a Justice Department lawyer by asking another service member, “If you were at Fox Hall.”
Click to get the Fox News app
She went on to suggest that Lynch was happy to be next to someone who had their admiration and courage.
Lynch agreed that in the situation he doubted that gender identity was in his heart.
