A Judge Rules Kyrsten Sinema Can Be Sued Under North Carolina’s “Homewrecker Law”

A federal judge has determined that former Senator Kyrsten Sinema (I-AZ) can be subject to a lawsuit under North Carolina’s “homewrecker law” in relation to her involvement with a married man from her security detail.

Sinema acknowledged having an affair with Matthew Ammel in 2024, yet her lawyers contended that she cannot be pursued legally in North Carolina due to a lack of connection to the state.

On Friday, U.S. District Judge David A. Bragdon rejected her request to dismiss the civil suit filed by Ammel’s ex-wife, Heather Ammel.

The judge noted that Ammel received nine texts from Sinema while at his home in North Carolina, establishing enough of a connection for the state to have jurisdiction over the case.

“These messages, taken together, suggest Ms. Sinema was actively building a romantic connection with Mr. Ammel—intruding into the marriage not only during trips but also while he was at home with his family,” the judge commented in his ruling.

The lawsuit further claims that Sinema attempted to address Ammel’s PTSD resulting from his military service in the Middle East using a potent psychedelic drug.

Shortly after the suit was filed in late 2025, a report emerged detailing sensational allegations, including claims that Sinema requested Ammel to bring MDMA on a work trip for a psychedelic experience, and that she had inappropriate discussions with him regarding sexual scenarios.

MDMA, known also as ecstasy or molly, is a recreational drug that heightens sensory experiences. Although it has been explored for therapeutic uses, the FDA last year did not approve it as a remedy for PTSD.

While studies have highlighted the potential of hallucinogenic treatments for trauma and depression, such therapies are typically conducted in controlled settings with licensed professionals.

Sinema holds a master’s degree in social work and later became a law professor at Arizona State University. She was a Democrat before becoming an independent in 2022 and served as a U.S. senator from 2019 until 2025.

North Carolina is among a few states allowing lawsuits for “alienation of affection,” as various news sources have noted.

In her lawsuit, Heather Ammel claims the couple had a “good and loving marriage” filled with “genuine love and affection” until Sinema’s interference, pursuing her husband despite being aware of his marital status.

The civil lawsuit can proceed, with Heather Ammel seeking a minimum of $75,000 in damages from Sinema.