Paris is in turmoil again. After weeks of unrest and thousands of arrests, French authorities have also opened a formal investigation into one of the country’s best-known novelists over comments about Islam that he made four years ago.
The protests began in September, amid anger over conditions in French schools. By October 17, frustration over living costs and public services had spilled into looting, arson, and clashes in the streets. Businesses were damaged, and the bill was reported to exceed 1 billion euros. Whatever the original grievances, setting fire to public buildings and smashing shops are crimes, not political arguments.
France has made mass arrests, brought prosecutions, and restricted demonstrations, so it would be inaccurate to say the government has ignored the rioting. Still, the investigation of a novelist’s remarks raises another question: why is his speech being treated as a criminal matter amid all this disorder?
On November 10, a judge placed Michel Houellebecq under formal investigation over alleged complicity in inciting discrimination, hatred, or violence against a religious or ethnic group. The case concerns a 2022 interview in which he predicted attacks on mosques and cafés frequented by Muslims, calling them “Bataclans in reverse.” He also said Muslims should stop stealing and assaulting people or leave France.
They were harsh words. But predicting violence is not necessarily the same as urging people to commit it. Houellebecq’s lawyers say he incited no one and that his remarks are protected by freedom of expression. The Union of Mosques of France and an anti-racism group have filed complaints, but he has not been convicted.
This is not to say Houellebecq was especially tactful. It is to say that a country confident in its freedoms should be able to challenge a novelist’s views without putting him through criminal proceedings for expressing them. France has endured real Islamist terrorist attacks. Yet President Emmanuel Macron’s government seems more focused on policing speech than on the persistent turmoil around it.
And this is not only a French concern. Consider New Jersey.
Assembly Bill A1146 would create a state definition of “Islamophobia” for public officials and law enforcement to use when examining discrimination complaints. Some of its examples describe attacks, harassment, and exclusion directed at Muslims. Those acts should already be taken seriously under the law.
But the proposal goes further, including “mendacious, dehumanizing, demonizing, or stereotypical” claims about Muslims. Its examples include assertions that Muslims pose a demographic threat or seek to take over, as well as claims that Muslim Americans are more loyal to a transnational community than to the United States.
When does an argument about political influence become a “stereotype”? Who gets to decide what counts as a “myth”? It is troubling to see those judgments spelled out for state officials.
The bill includes a First Amendment safeguard and does not itself make criticism of Islam a crime. That is welcome, though it does not resolve the concern. Official definitions can shape investigations long before a court has a chance to weigh in.
Virginia has proposed a narrower approach. State Sen. Saddam Azlan Salim sponsored Senate Bill 624, which has been carried over to the 2027 session. It would define “Islamophobia” as malicious prejudice or hatred toward Islam or Muslims for the purposes of existing assault-and-battery law and hate-crime reporting. The definition would also cover people targeted because someone mistakenly believes they are Muslim.
The Virginia bill says it creates no separate offense and does not limit speech protected by the First Amendment. That is a meaningful difference from New Jersey’s lengthy list of examples. Even so, why should the government define hostility toward one religion specifically, rather than apply the law equally to threats and violence against anyone?
America should be more stubborn than Europe on this point. People who assault Muslims, Christians, Jews, atheists, or anyone else should face the law. Their freedom to worship should be protected, as should everyone’s freedom to question religious beliefs.
Criticism of Islam is not automatically hatred of Muslims, just as criticism of Christianity is not automatically hatred of Christians. Arguments about immigration, crime, and religious doctrine do not become illegitimate simply because officials find them offensive. The First Amendment protects unpleasant opinions along with agreeable ones. That matters most when tempers are running high.
Paris is not a warning about what might happen. It is a warning about what is already happening. France has absorbed deep cultural tensions through mass immigration, then turned its attention toward people who criticize the consequences. America can still choose a different course. If officials begin policing debate about Islam, immigration, and assimilation, we risk importing not only Europe’s problems but also the rules that make those problems harder to discuss.
First come the conflicts. Then come the rules against talking about them.


