Millions of Americans are spending the weekend in Vice City, stepping into the criminal world of “Grand Theft Auto VI.” Rockstar’s new game follows Jason and Lucia as they try to make their way through a dangerous world together. Their relationship gives the story a touch of old-fashioned romance: when people break the law for someone they love, it can start to seem as though they’re making a noble sacrifice.
Being a successful criminal takes discipline. There are plans to make, people to coordinate with, and police to avoid. It sounds exhausting. Players who spend weeks, months, or even years learning every corner of this vast game also need plenty of discipline.
Parents may understandably worry about a game that turns violence and vice into entertainment, especially if their children are playing it. But there’s another point worth considering: the game offers a picture of what it means to be ruled by sin. Its characters pursue love, loyalty, and happiness through crime. Those desires give their efforts a purpose. But do they make the choices right?
Criminals can be disciplined. So can addicts chasing a fix, or people consumed by the pursuit of money, fame, power, or pleasure. Discipline serves a purpose; by itself, it doesn’t tell us whether that purpose is good.
We often treat discipline as a virtue on its own. Really, it means directing our will toward a goal and continuing despite distractions or setbacks. The harder question is whether we have chosen the right goal. A highly organized thief may have discipline to spare, but his purpose is still wrong. Someone can plan every hour of the day and spend a lifetime pursuing something that doesn’t matter.
Think of someone who gets up and goes to work when they would rather take a holiday. Earning money and paying the bills may be the immediate aim. But if they are doing it to support their family, that larger purpose gives the daily effort meaning. It also raises a bigger question: what is the highest good we should be working toward?
Discipline calls for diligence, the steady effort to keep going over time. Ask a small business owner how much a diligent employee matters. It also takes perseverance. Retired Navy SEAL Jocko Willink has a famously brief response to setbacks: “Good.” Difficulties can give us a chance to improve, as long as we don’t give up. We won’t get far if we abandon a goal at the first obstacle. These habits can help us reach what we’re aiming for, whether that aim is admirable or corrupt.
Ancient philosophers saw another challenge: the conflict between reason and desire. You might decide to cut back on sugar for your health, then find the cookies at a meeting much more tempting than the promise of feeling better someday.
Aristotle described this as weakness of the will: we make sensible plans, then give in to our appetites. His proposed answer was to develop good habits. Picture two people trying to avoid drunkenness. One desperately wants a drink and has to fight that urge over and over. The other has built a habit of moderation and feels less drawn to drinking. Both make the right choice, but only one has learned to want it.
The Stoics saw self-command as a kind of freedom. Someone who can govern their appetites can act on considered judgment instead of whatever feels urgent in the moment. A person controlled by those appetites becomes their servant. Doing whatever we feel like may look like freedom, but it can turn into another form of captivity.
Still, self-control alone doesn’t answer the question of what we should want.
Imagine a man who spends a year preparing an elaborate project. He gets up early, works late, builds connections, and pushes through setbacks. His discipline is impressive. The project is a bank robbery. Give the thief’s story the romance of a video game, and we might even find ourselves cheering him on. We’ve admired his determination without asking whether his goal deserves that admiration.
Christianity offers an answer that goes beyond forming good habits. It teaches that human beings are born enslaved to sin. We’re drawn to what is corrupt, while what is good and holy can seem dull or demanding. That helps explain why people may hate sin’s consequences and still love the sin itself.
We can urge someone to stop doing something destructive. We can suggest better routines, more willpower, and stronger self-control. But what if the person doesn’t want to stop? What if the deeper problem is what they love?
The Christian response, then, is more radical than self-improvement. We need a new heart, one that loves what is good, true, and holy. The world often tells us to try harder and become more effective at getting what we want. Good habits do matter. Still, our biggest problem may be that we don’t want what is truly good.
We need transformed hearts, not just stronger wills. We need to learn to love what is worth wanting.
That is why Jesus didn’t tell Nicodemus simply to try harder. He told him, “You must be born again.”


