Heisman Trophy Race Heating Up

Is the competition for the 2025 Heisman Trophy now limited to just four quarterbacks? Recent odds suggest so. Indiana’s Fernando Mendoza is currently leading, just ahead of Ohio State’s Julian Sain, with Texas A&M’s Marcell Reed and Alabama’s Ty Simpson also in the mix.

Let’s break down these four quarterbacks and their chances. There are, of course, several others still with a shot at making a statement in New York City.

First, we dive into the frontrunners.

1. Fernando Mendoza, QB, Indiana

Gus Johnson couldn’t contain his excitement, calling Mendoza’s game-winning touchdown pass to Omar Cooper in last week’s nail-biter against Penn State his potential Heisman moment. With the Hoosiers sitting at 10-0, Mendoza led a thrilling comeback that solidified their undefeated season thus far. It’s worth noting that if Indiana continues this momentum and secures a spot in the Big Ten Championship, it could very well clinch the Heisman for him before the championship game even occurs, given that voting begins December 1st.

And should Indiana finish unbeaten, it would be a historic achievement—the first time since 1945. Heisman voters tend to gravitate towards compelling stories.

2. Marcell Reed, QB, Texas A&M

While Mendoza has the narrow edge over Sain, Reed’s path to the Heisman appears quite favorable. The Aggies are currently 9-0, largely due to Reed’s impressive performance, including setting up 19 passing touchdowns against formidable opponents. The upcoming matchups—against South Carolina and then a high-stakes rivalry game against Texas—could provide Reed with the opportunity to shine on a national stage.

A finish this season without a loss would mark Texas A&M’s first since 1994 and could parallel their last undefeated season in 1939. It’s certainly a narrative that resonates.

3. Julian Sain, QB, Ohio State University

Sain has the second-best Heisman odds, largely because Ohio State remains undefeated and holds the No. 1 ranking nationally. This season, he has also been statistically one of the most efficient passers—a factor that traditionally favors Heisman candidates. However, it may be challenging for him this year due to Ohio State’s less demanding schedule, with upcoming games against lesser-ranked teams. A standout performance against Michigan could potentially reshape the narrative.

4. Ty Simpson, QB, Alabama

It’s been a while since Alabama faced defeat, and they’ve consistently brought home wins against ranked teams. Simpson’s impressive stats, including completing 69% of his passes for over 1,000 yards this season, elevate his profile. Even if he might not snag the award this time around, his resume certainly warrants consideration as a finalist.

Other Notable Heisman Candidates

It’s always exciting to watch the rise of underdogs. Here are some other players to watch as the season winds down.

5. Diego Pavia, QB, Vanderbilt

If you’re seeking an underdog story, Pavia fits the bill perfectly. Since taking over as the starting quarterback, he has turned Vanderbilt’s fortunes around significantly, as they’re now in contention for the playoffs. With upcoming games against Kentucky and Tennessee, will he make a lasting impression?

6. Haynes King, QB, Georgia Tech

The Yellow Jackets have surged to prominence this season, and King has been pivotal in their success. His impressive rush yards and touchdowns might catch the attention of Heisman voters, especially if he can deliver a compelling performance against Georgia.

7. Jeremiah Smith, WR, Ohio State University

Smith’s performance has been notable for a wide receiver, ranking highly in receiving yards and touchdowns. A standout showing against Michigan could keep his name in the Heisman conversation.

8. Jeremiah Love, RB, Notre Dame

Love is making a strong case with his record-setting rushing touchdowns this season. Yet, trends favoring quarterbacks may hinder his chances, especially since Notre Dame’s season concludes earlier than others’—offering less opportunity to impress voters.

9. Jacob Rodriguez, LB, Texas Tech

Rodriguez has recently gained recognition, and his achievements are impressive. Leading the nation in forced fumbles and interceptions adds to his appeal. However, the history of defensive players winning the Heisman is bleak, and that could be a significant hurdle for him.