How Bob Woodward betrayed the person who brought him fame

How Bob Woodward betrayed the person who brought him fame

Bob Woodward’s upcoming memoir, “Secrets: A Reporter’s Memoir,” names confidential sources who trusted him to keep their identities private. Many of those people have since died, and critics say revealing their names breaks promises they could no longer defend. To understand why so many powerful people trusted Woodward, it helps to look at how he handled the source who first made him famous: W. Mark Felt, the senior FBI official known as Deep Throat.

When Woodward and Carl Bernstein published “All the President’s Men” in 1974, some of its most compelling scenes described Woodward’s secret meetings with Deep Throat. Felt helped the reporters pursue the Watergate story, which contributed to President Richard Nixon’s downfall. Woodward’s apparent commitment to shielding his source also helped establish him as a journalist people could confide in without expecting to be named.

That reputation made Woodward a leading chronicler of government insiders. Officials with sensitive information could approach him, whether out of principle or a desire for revenge, believing their names would stay out of the paper. But I always thought the famous example of his discretion showed its limits, too.

I was 27 and working as a federal prosecutor when “All the President’s Men” came out. Even then, I questioned whether Woodward had truly protected Deep Throat. Felt had a great deal at stake beyond his anonymity: his own standing and the reputation of the FBI, an institution he cared about. Yet Woodward included clues about his source’s knowledge, speech, manner, and place in the government.

Taken together, those details pointed toward a senior FBI official. By the fall of 1974, I thought the case for Felt’s identity was strong. After the movie came out in 1976, I was convinced beyond a reasonable doubt. It didn’t take unusual brilliance, just patience and some familiarity with the federal justice system.

Take one clue. Deep Throat told Woodward about Nixon’s anger over leaked stories. That might have led readers to think the source worked in the White House. But Woodward also wrote that Nixon had berated acting FBI Director L. Patrick Gray about leaks. Gray could have told Felt, a close associate, about the exchange. In that light, the clue pointed toward the FBI. Woodward never claimed that Deep Throat had personally witnessed Nixon’s outburst.

Another clue involved wiretaps on Henry Kissinger. Deep Throat discussed them with Woodward at a roadside bar in early 1973. I concluded that only eight government officials had the necessary knowledge. Seven seemed unlikely as sources, leaving Felt as the most plausible candidate.

I explored these clues in my 2019 book, “Postgate.” The point here is more straightforward: Woodward was praised for protecting an anonymous source while publishing enough information to make the man identifiable. For decades, Felt lived as though he were trying to avoid searchlights in a prison yard. That was not much like the arrangement he believed he had entered.

Felt wanted the Watergate investigation to proceed without political interference or a cover-up that might damage the FBI. He worried that narrowing the inquiry, including its examination of Donald Segretti’s dirty-tricks operation, would undermine the bureau’s integrity. But if the public discovered that an FBI official had been leaking information, the bureau could suffer the very reputational harm Felt hoped to prevent.

Woodward’s portrayal of Deep Throat served the reporter’s story, but I don’t think it served the source. Rather than treating Woodward as a champion of confidentiality, we should see him as a remarkably successful journalist who took advantage of a source’s trust—and, in important ways, failed him.

In 2002, I learned that my daughter, then in college, had become friends with Felt’s grandson. I met Felt at his family home and later became his lawyer. He had found it difficult even to admit his role to his relatives. “An FBI man,” he told me, “does not act like that.” His daughter and grandsons encouraged him to tell his story while he still had the chance.

We also understood that Woodward planned to identify Deep Throat after Felt died. That would leave Felt unable to explain his actions or respond to whatever Woodward wrote about the FBI. With his family behind him, Felt eventually chose to go public. I wrote the account published in Vanity Fair in 2005.

I still believe Woodward acted against Felt’s interests, particularly when it came to the possibility of making money from books and films. I describe that disagreement in “Postgate.” The larger issue isn’t limited to Felt: reporters and their sources can need each other while wanting very different things.

Woodward’s new disclosures bring me back to the question I had in 1974: What does a promise of confidentiality amount to if the reporter gets to decide, on their own, when it ends? A source may be gone, but the effects on a person’s reputation, family, or institution can last.

If journalists had followed the clues and identified Felt decades ago, perhaps other sources would have realized that Woodward’s celebrated protection offered less security than they assumed. There may be honor among thieves. Felt learned, at least, that he could not count on much from the reporter who made him famous.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News