A sequel to the 2018 hit film, I Can Only Imagine, continues the tale of Bart Millard from MercyMe and explores his complicated relationship with his father. This theme of redemption remains central to the story, much like the original.
In the new film, Millard, portrayed as a successful artist, faces the shadows of his past that threaten his career. His journey takes a pivotal turn when he meets fellow Christian musician Tim Timmons, who guides him in rediscovering gratitude and helps mend his connection with his wife and son.
Similar to the first installment, this sequel emphasizes music, featuring the song Parable, co-written by Timmons and the band. It’s produced by Kingdom Story Company.
Directed by Andrew Irwin and Brent McCorkle, the film brings back John Michael Finley as Millard, alongside Sophie Skelton, Milo Ventimiglia, and Arielle Kebbell, with Trace Adkins and Dennis Quaid reprising their roles.
“We had such a great time with I Can Only Imagine eight years ago, and although going back never seemed feasible, Bart and MercyMe continue to inspire with their lives,” Irwin shared with Crosswalk Headlines.
The Kingdom Stories team felt there were “more stories to tell,” emphasized Irwin. The narrative behind Parable features a poignant father-son dynamic between Timmons and his son, culminating in the song’s creation.
The first film captured a cheerful tone, but this new one addresses what comes after those happy days, ultimately culminating in a message of gratitude. It tells a beautiful story, according to Irwin.
Millard expressed that the film conveys a strong message about God’s peace and guidance during difficult times.
“Even at our peak, we faced struggles, and I hope people can connect with that,” Millard stated. “Life continues, regardless of your accolades.”
The original film was a box office success, earning $83 million in the U.S. and ranking among the top 40 films of that year.
Timmons mentioned that the film’s themes resonate universally.
“Everyone experiences grief,” he noted. “This film invites people to spend time with Jesus amid their sadness and gratitude.”
First publication date is October 22, 2025.
