Jennifer Sey challenges Colorado law over speech concerns
Jennifer Sey says she does not trust Colorado to leave her business alone. The founder of XX-XY Athletics is suing the state, arguing that a 2025 law could force the company to give up language central to its opposition to biological males competing in women’s sports.
The stakes could be serious. Hal Frampton, a lawyer representing the company, says violations of Colorado’s anti-discrimination law can bring fines of up to $3,500. Some advertising violations, he says, may also be treated as Class 2 misdemeanors, carrying a possible jail term of up to 120 days.
Colorado has not taken enforcement action against XX-XY Athletics since the law passed. The state has pointed to that record in arguing that the company should not receive legal protection while its case moves forward. Sey says that is no comfort to her.
“Then why have the law?” she said, arguing that the state’s position amounts to asking her to trust officials not to use it. “I don’t trust you.”
The dispute centers on the Kelly Loving Act, also known as HB 25-1312. The law broadened Colorado’s anti-discrimination protections to cover a person’s chosen name and preferred forms of address. Sey and her lawyers contend that businesses could be required to use pronouns or titles that conflict with their beliefs.
After arguments Monday at the 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, Sey’s legal team is seeking protection before a complaint is filed. Frampton, senior counsel at Alliance Defending Freedom, said people should not have to wait for prosecution to challenge a law they believe violates the Constitution.
XX-XY Athletics has made its position on sex in sports a prominent part of its public messaging. Sey, a former national gymnastics champion and Levi’s executive, started the apparel company in 2024 to support women’s sports. Its advertising and social media posts have criticized the participation of biological males in female competitions.
Earlier this month, Sey also helped lead a campaign for Proposition 134, which Colorado voters approved with about 52% support. The measure requires K-12 and college sports teams to be designated male, female or coed, with eligibility generally based on biological sex. It is set to take effect Jan. 1.
Sey described the campaign as difficult, saying it relied on more than 3,000 volunteers and had far fewer resources than opponents, who she said spent nearly $4.5 million. Still, she believes the state’s anti-discrimination law could limit how openly her company discusses the issue.
She argues that the two laws are in conflict: if the company cannot use its preferred language, she says, it may be unable to speak plainly about the sports policies it opposes.
The lawsuit points to the company’s practice of referring to transgender-identifying male athletes according to their biological sex. One post cited in the case discussed a male athlete competing in girls’ high-school track in Pennsylvania and said that when boys compete in girls’ events, boys win and girls lose.
Sey’s lawyers say the state’s expanded definition of gender expression could expose statements like that to discrimination complaints. Frampton argued that simply hoping no one files a complaint is not a sensible way for the company to proceed.
For Sey, the concern is not limited to the possibility of a fine or lawsuit. She believes that requiring businesses to use language they reject could make it harder to challenge the policies they oppose. If the athletes are called girls, she argued, the underlying dispute becomes harder to see.
A federal judge rejected XX-XY Athletics’ request for a preliminary injunction in March, finding that the company had not shown a sufficiently credible threat that the law would be enforced against it. The decision did not resolve whether the law violates the First Amendment; it found only that the company had not established a basis for immediate protection while the case continues.
Colorado says XX-XY Athletics has overstated the risk. At Monday’s hearing, state lawyer Janna Fischer argued that the plaintiffs were seeking an unusually broad order that would let them misgender or deadname people without consequence.
Fischer also maintained that the 2025 law did not change substantive rights under the Colorado Anti-Discrimination Act. She said the state’s Civil Rights Division looks for a denial of service or behavior that amounts to harassment, rather than treating misgendering or deadnaming alone as sufficient.
Sey says the case matters beyond her company, arguing that the law could leave businesses and individuals afraid to speak openly.
The lawsuit is the latest in a series of Colorado disputes over free speech that have reached the U.S. Supreme Court. In 2018, the court ruled for baker Jack Phillips in the Masterpiece Cakeshop case, finding that state officials had shown hostility toward his religious beliefs. In 2023, it ruled in 303 Creative that Colorado could not compel a website designer to create expressive work conveying a message she opposed. Earlier this year, the court sided with a Colorado counselor challenging restrictions on certain conversations with clients in Chiles v. Salazar.
Frampton cited those cases and questioned why, in his view, Colorado had not learned from them.
Colorado’s governor-elect, Phil Weiser, has said Proposition 134 may be revisited. Because it is a statute rather than a constitutional amendment, lawmakers can change it. At a post-election news conference, Weiser said the state would need to consider what adjustments to its policies on transgender issues might be appropriate.
Sey, who spent two years working to pass Proposition 134, pushed back on the idea. She warned that overturning the measure so soon after voters approved it would be politically damaging, and said she would make sure people knew if it happened.






