John Madden deserves a great biopic. Amazon disrespects him.

John Madden deserves a great biopic. Amazon disrespects him.

Before getting into David O. Russell’s new film for Prime Video, it helps to remember who John Madden was. The movie, unfortunately, seems to lose sight of that.

Madden was born in Austin, Minnesota, in 1936 and grew up in Daly City, California. He became a major figure in sports and American culture. A knee injury ended his hopes of playing for the Eagles, so he turned to coaching. At 32, he took charge of the Oakland Raiders. Over the next decade, his teams went 103-32-7 in the regular season, the best winning percentage among NFL coaches with at least 100 wins. The Raiders’ Super Bowl XI victory in 1977 capped that run.

Exhausted and suffering from serious ulcers, Madden left coaching at 42 and found a new career in broadcasting. For three decades, he became a familiar presence on Sunday afternoons. In 1988, he also lent his name and voice to Electronic Arts for “Madden NFL.”

The game introduced a lot of kids, me included, to the deeper strategies of football. It was a genuine breakthrough, and by 2018 the series had sold more than 130 million copies around the world. Madden was a sharp strategist, an unusually gifted communicator, and a one-of-a-kind figure.

A cinematic fumble

That history makes the 110-minute film feel less like a tribute than a very public misfire. Released Wednesday, “Madden” had an 18% Rotten Tomatoes score as of Thursday. It’s oddly unfunny and all over the place, treating one of sports’ most beloved figures as a joke without bothering to build much of a setup.

The movie is a strange exercise in tonal whiplash, largely because its two leads seem to be in entirely different films. Nicolas Cage plays Madden as a broad, distracting caricature. Christian Bale, meanwhile, gives the kind of carefully observed performance that makes you wonder how he ended up in this movie.

“Awful” doesn’t quite capture Cage’s portrayal. It’s a screen version of the Butt Fumble: easy enough to identify as a disaster, harder to describe without seeing it. At 62, Cage is buried under padding, prosthetics, and a wig that looks rather like it was pulled from a soaked golden retriever.

Instead of showing Madden’s football smarts, warmth, or working-class charm, Cage leans on bulging eyes, sweaty mannerisms, loud outbursts, and clumsy slapstick. He stumbles through major moments in Madden’s life, from leaving the Raiders to working with Pat Summerall and meeting EA founder Trip Hawkins, with little sense of what’s going on beneath the performance. There’s almost no nuance or humanity. A larger-than-life man is reduced to a noisy fool.

Craft versus caricature

When Bale appears as Raiders owner Al Davis, the film briefly becomes easier to watch. His transformation feels rooted in acting rather than layers of padding. With a convincing Brooklyn accent, slicked-back hair, oversized sunglasses, and a quietly menacing presence, Bale makes Davis both commanding and compelling. He captures the owner’s intensity and loyalty, along with a gruff affection for his increasingly stressed coach. Cage is all commotion; Bale barely needs to raise his voice.

One of the film’s few effective scenes comes when Davis dismisses Madden’s painful stomach problems with a flat “gas,” just before the seriousness of his bleeding ulcer becomes clear. Bale is good whenever the movie gives him space. It’s hard not to think about what this could have been with a director more willing to treat the material seriously.

The gap between the two performances is almost surreal. When Bale and Cage share a scene, it can feel as though a gritty 1970s drama has wandered into a cheap sketch show. Bale is working with restraint and precision while Cage, a few feet away, throws himself into full-body contortions in a fat suit.

Superficial spectacle

Russell appears not to notice the film’s clashing tones, and his other choices only make matters worse. The supporting cast includes Kathryn Hahn as Virginia Madden, Sienna Miller as Carol Davis, and John Mulaney as Trip Hawkins, but they’re given thin material that leaves little for them to do. A made-up character played by comedian Shane Gillis, along with former NFL players Julian Edelman and Marshawn Lynch appearing as EA programmers, makes the film feel like a shallow Super Bowl ad that has lost track of what it’s advertising.

The archival footage is another problem. In one scene, Madden and Summerall sit in a 1970s broadcast booth, then the film cuts to 1990s footage of Cowboys lineman Nate Newton, complete with Fox Sports graphics that didn’t belong in that earlier era. If a football biopic can’t keep its footage in the right decade, it’s difficult to feel confident about the rest of its details.

Ultimately, “Madden” fails because it misunderstands the man at its center. John Madden didn’t become an American icon by being a clueless loudmouth. He was exceptionally smart and could make the game understandable to people who had never watched a play. He deserved a thoughtful, genuinely good biopic. This one, sadly, feels like a film that should not have been made.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News