Federal Judge Delays End of Temporary Protected Status for Haitians

A federal judge has decided to maintain her order that puts a hold on the termination of Temporary Protected Status for numerous Haitians residing in the U.S.

The Justice Department, which disagrees with the ruling, has appealed U.S. District Judge Ana Reyes’ decision to the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals while also asking for the order to be overturned. However, after hearing arguments from both parties, Judge Reyes denied the government’s petition and indicated she would provide a written order by February 19, the deadline set by the appeals court.

This ruling effectively suspends the action by Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem that aimed to end the Temporary Protected Status for Haitians.

“During the stay, the dismissal shall be null and void and have no legal effect,” Reyes stated, emphasizing that individuals will still benefit from protections previously granted under the TPS designation. This includes work permits and protection against detention and deportation, with work permit validity extended for the duration of the stay.

Reyes mentioned at the conclusion of the hearing that she wanted to record something “important.” “People have a right to be heard,” she said, reflecting on her own identity as the first Latina woman and openly LGBTQ judge on the D.C. district bench.

Reyes shared her experiences as an immigrant, acknowledging the skepticism she faced, including rhetorical questions about her qualifications for her position.

She noted that she had never heard anyone talk about her professional background, including a Harvard Law School graduation with honors and 22 years working at a prominent law firm.

At one point, Reyes read alarming text messages she received in threats against her. “I don’t mind being called the C-word,” she remarked, detailing some disturbing messages like wishes for her death. She highlighted that judges and their families have faced threats, asserting, “To those who threaten our judges…we will act without fear or favor. We will continue our work. We will not be intimidated.”