You can listen to news articles now.
If you or someone you know is struggling with suicidal thoughts, please reach out to the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline at 1-800-273-TALK (8255).
Prosecutors seem to be gradually dismantling the defense’s narrative suggesting that Lindsay Clancy overdosed, having jurors hand over nine prescription bottles that still had many pills inside.
Patrick Clancy testified that his ex-wife was given several psychiatric medications in the months leading up to the tragic deaths of their three young children. However, when Assistant District Attorney Shanann Buckingham cross-examined him, he conceded that some of these prescriptions were only partially used.
“I mean, I was prescribed a lot of medication, but I didn’t take a lot, right?” Buckingham asked while holding a bag containing prescription meds.
Patrick noted that the situation for Lindsay felt like a “big spiral.” He responded, “That’s not that surprising, no.”
Former federal prosecutor Neema Rahmani pointed out that the questioning seemed designed to limit the defense’s ability to shape jurors’ perceptions regarding the array of medications Lindsay Clancy was on before she allegedly killed her children—Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and Callan, 8 months—in January 2023 at their Duxbury home. Prosecutors characterized the children’s deaths as “deliberate and meticulous murders,” portraying their mother as a calculated killer.
During cross-examination, Buckingham sought to differentiate between the total prescriptions given over several months and how many Lindsay would have at any one time. Patrick estimated she was taking no more than three or four medications concurrently. When asked whether Lindsay would be surprised to learn she typically had only two drugs at a time, he responded vaguely, perhaps realizing that the situation was more nuanced than it appeared.
Rahmani explained that the focus would likely shift to how long Lindsay had been on each medication, when she stopped taking them, and how many different drugs were prescribed simultaneously. He mentioned that it’s common for psychiatrists to rotate medications, stopping those that don’t seem effective, making the prosecution’s case potentially stronger.
In his opening statement, defense attorney Kevin Reddington admitted that Clancy did kill her children but emphasized that the crux of the matter lies in understanding her mental state at that time. “She knows she killed her children,” he reiterated, “but the question is what was going on in her mind.”
Lindsay Clancy, a previous labor and delivery nurse at Massachusetts General Hospital, has pleaded not guilty to three counts of murder and strangulation. The trial could take six to eight weeks, with a long list of witnesses expected to testify.
Judge William Sullivan instructed the jurors that the prosecution must convincingly show that Clancy was criminally responsible when the killings occurred.
