Lisa Rinna and Colton Underwood had some unresolved issues when the cast of *Traitors* Season 4 got together for the reunion taping on Thursday.
Sources have shared that Rinna, aged 62, confronted Underwood, 34, over her earlier use of the term “hostage” while discussing Rinna’s role as a presumed traitor during the season.
Apparently, Rinna’s reputation as an experienced “housewife” with a sharp tongue made Underwood a bit unprepared for the intensity of their exchange.
It was reportedly noted that Underwood left the set after the confrontation, with conflicting accounts surrounding the nature of his exit; some say he was upset, while others believe it aligned with a scheduled break.
After this, he returned to the set looking more composed, apparently having taken a moment to gather himself.
Neither representatives for Rinna, Underwood, nor Peacock immediately responded to inquiries regarding the reunion.
Throughout the airing season, Underwood, who played as Faithful, had expressed concerns about Rinna being a traitor and had suggested he might take her “hostage.”
In a tense moment, he pulled Rinna aside, promising to shield her from being excluded at the Round Table, on the condition she wouldn’t try to have him eliminated from the game.
Rinna firmly denied being a traitor and refused to negotiate, which led to Underwood being proactive in trying to remove her from the game. (He eventually faced elimination himself.)
After a particular episode aired, Rinna took to social media to comment, “Let’s talk about you being a stalker…” addressing Underwood’s past.
Underwood, who came out as gay in April 2021, previously dated Cassie Randolph from March 2019 until their breakup in May 2020, which led to allegations of stalking between the two.
Randolph had claimed that Underwood harassed her with troubling messages and even put a tracking device on her car.
Following Rinna’s “stalker” remarks gaining attention, she appealed to fans on Instagram to be considerate, explaining that her remarks were made in the context of playing the game.
She added, “Please don’t send death threats or do anything that puts your family at risk.” In response, Peacock condemned any form of “cyberbullying” or “personal attacks.”
