New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani faced questions Wednesday about his approach to antisemitism during an appearance at the DealBook Summit.
After opening by greeting his “comrades,” Mamdani was asked by interviewer Andrew Ross Sorkin about his choice of words when discussing Jewish New Yorkers and rising antisemitism.
Sorkin cited a post Mamdani published on X marking the Oct. 7 attack on Israel. The post devoted more attention to Palestinians and Israel’s military response in Gaza than to the roughly 1,200 people killed by Hamas in the attack.
Sorkin also noted that a leader of the Reform Jewish movement had said the statement made New Yorkers feel less safe. A rabbi who supports Mamdani had asked whether the community could have “just one day” to mourn. Sorkin added that Jewish people are the targets of about 53% of hate crimes in New York City, and asked whether that gave Mamdani a particular responsibility to choose his words carefully.
Mamdani challenged the idea that his post represented everything he did that day. He said he attended a vigil for the victims, as he had the year before, and was criticized for going.
“My politics is one that believes that there has to be room to mourn everyone,” Mamdani said. He said he had condemned the Oct. 7 attack as a war crime and opposed violations of international law regardless of who commits them. He also defended his criticism of Israel’s government.
Mamdani called the share of hate crimes targeting Jewish New Yorkers “unacceptable,” noting that Jews make up about 10% to 12% of the city’s population. He said he was proud to lead the largest Jewish city in the United States and that the city must confront antisemitism and all forms of bigotry.
He acknowledged that some Jewish New Yorkers, as well as residents of other faiths or no faith, disagree with him about Israel and Palestine. His responsibility, he said, was to serve them and work to make the city better for everyone who lives there.
Sorkin then asked whether Mamdani would consider posting on Oct. 7 about the horror of the attack, and waiting until Oct. 8 to criticize Israel’s response. The question drew applause from the audience.
Mamdani replied that the Israeli government’s conduct in Gaza was often defended by referring back to Oct. 7, regardless of when the issue came up. He said the attack was a horrific war crime, but had also been used to justify what followed, and that the day should be understood in terms of its full impact.
He said he understood the opposing view but stood by his emphasis on applying empathy and universal values to both Israelis and Palestinians.






