New York City has issued more than $500 million in bills through Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s disputed tax on luxury second homes. But far fewer owners were billed than the city initially expected.
“We’ve billed more than $500 million to owners of second homes worth more than $5 million,” Mamdani wrote on X on Tuesday, adding that the money would help fund city services for New Yorkers.
The city’s Department of Finance sent out about 7,500 bills, according to information from officials. That’s well below the roughly 17,000 notices sent to property owners over the summer. Officials said about 8,900 exemption requests were approved and around 1,600 requests for extensions were denied.
The surcharge, often called a pied-à-terre tax, is part of Mamdani’s plan to raise revenue from wealthy property owners and address the city’s budget gap. The amount billed has exceeded the $500 million target Governor Kathy Hochul outlined earlier this year, despite the smaller number of bills.
Officials have not yet provided a breakdown of how the total was calculated across the properties billed. The tax uses a sliding scale, so owners of higher-value homes may owe more.
A report from the city comptroller’s office in April estimated that a version of the tax could bring in about $500 million from more than 11,200 properties, before factoring in exemptions or changes in owner behavior. Once those factors were considered, the report projected revenue of roughly $340 million to $380 million.
Mamdani has remained confident in the tax’s potential. Last week, he told reporters the city expected it to raise $500 million a year.
Approved by the state Legislature in May, the surcharge applies to qualifying luxury second homes in New York City. These include certain one- to three-family homes valued at $5 million or more, as well as condos and co-ops worth at least $1 million. Owners who qualify for an exemption do not have to pay it.
The announcement follows a legal win for Mamdani earlier this month, when a state appeals court unanimously dismissed a lawsuit challenging the tax’s rollout. The court ruled that the homeowners who filed the case lacked standing, reversing a lower court decision that had directed the city to restart implementation.
Other legal challenges remain, including questions about whether the tax is constitutional.






