As the college football season approaches, Matt Leinart, a former Heisman-winning quarterback from USC and current Fox analyst, chats with Steve Serby about various Heisman candidates.
Q: Let’s discuss some potential Heisman contenders like Arch Manning.
A: Last year, I think there was a lot of pressure on him, mostly due to the hype surrounding his name. The expectations were sky-high for sure. When he faced Ohio State in Week 1, things didn’t go smoothly, but, really, their defense is top-notch. After that, he seemed to find his groove, and we saw why everyone was so eager to watch him play. His potential is enormous, and, with a strong roster from Texas, I see him as a front-runner this season. Of course, anything can change, but I expect great things from him.
Q: What stands out about his game?
A: He’s got an impressive build and big legs—definitely the type of quarterback we see in today’s game who can both run and pass effectively. Personally, I focus less on arm strength and speed; the leadership qualities and demeanor really matter to me. How does he handle himself on the field? In interviews? Arch has that essence that makes you think, “This is someone I want leading my team.” Despite the potential to cash in on NIL deals, he’s committed to being a player and putting in the hard work. That’s what resonates with me.
Q: How about Oregon’s Dante Moore?
A: He can throw the ball really well. He may not be the tallest, but he has a strong arm. What truly sets him apart is his mental game—he seems to always be in control. I’m glad he chose to return for another year; I think he’ll grow even more this season.
Q: And Ohio State’s Julian Sayin?
A: He’s another West Coast talent—a steady presence. His accuracy is remarkable. To come into a pressure-filled environment like Ohio State and thrive is impressive. He might not have flashy running skills, but his throwing ability is top tier. Knowing him since high school, I see how composed and calm he is. He’s a consistent performer.
Q: What about Ole Miss’s Trinidad Chambliss?
A: He’s intriguing—definitely a player to watch. With Lane Kiffin’s departure, it’ll be interesting to see how he adapts, but he could be a sleeper for the Heisman and possibly a top draft pick down the line. His skill set is top-notch, and he’s a key reason why Ole Miss is expected to do well this season.
Q: Notre Dame’s CJ Carr?
A: I see him as a future top-five pick. The sky is the limit for him. With a big load on his shoulders, especially after losing two running backs, I think we’ll see him throwing the ball more this season—something I’m really looking forward to.
Q: USC’s Jayden Maiava?
A: He’s entering his third season under coach Lincoln Riley—huge for him. Jayden has a lot of talent and runs the offense smoothly. I hope to see him emerge as a stronger leader; that’s what he needs to take his game to the next level. He has Heisman potential and could be a high draft pick.
Q: Miami’s Darian Mensah?
A: He’s another dual-threat quarterback. He performed at a high level at Duke, and now he’s at Miami, which is a big step up. I think he’ll showcase his talent more on a national level this season. He could give Miami a boost.
Q: SMU’s Cole Leinart?
A: He’s a young player still finding his footing, but there’s a lot of potential there. He’s got a strong arm and accuracy to match. If he can work hard in training, I think he’ll get his chance and make the most of it.
Q: What about Indiana?
A: I’m not sure if they’ll clinch another title, but Coach Curt Cignetti has shown he can build a solid team. They’ve lost some key players, but Cignetti’s talent for molding quarterbacks is impressive. With Josh Hoover from TCU now joining, their future looks brighter. Teams like Oregon and Ohio State seem to be at the top, while Indiana is right in the mix alongside others like USC and Penn State.
Q: How do you feel about Notre Dame’s prospects?
A: I can see Notre Dame as a contender for the Final Four. The offense needs to adjust after losing some top players, but I believe CJ Carr will step up. Their schedule seems manageable, and they’ve got a good shot at going undefeated.
Q: What about Georgia?
A: Georgia has solid potential this year, especially with Gunner Stockton returning as quarterback. Their young team won the SEC last year, and if they can become more explosive on offense, they’ll remain a strong contender in the SEC. I expect them to stay competitive with Texas, although I still lean toward Georgia for now.
Q: How’s the ACC looking?
A: Miami stands out as the team to beat. Don’t overlook SMU either; they shocked a lot of people last season and have a strong roster—could push for an ACC championship this year.
Q: What about the Big 12?
A: Texas Tech is shaping up to be good again, although their quarterback situation is concerning. BYU looks poised to win the Big 12, with Bear Bachmeier back. TCU could be another team to watch, and while Utah is losing their coach, the culture there might still keep them competitive.
Q: How do you rate Ohio State’s Jeremiah Smith?
A: He’s potentially the best player in college football right now. His talent is extraordinary, fitting in with past greats like Larry Fitzgerald and Julio Jones. It’s all a matter of getting the ball in his hands and letting him make plays.
Q: What other storylines are intriguing?
A: Coaching changes are always interesting—like Lane Kiffin moving to LSU. There’s a lot to unpack there, especially how he’ll manage such a talented roster. I’m also curious about Matt Campbell at Penn State; he might not be in the spotlight, but he’s a solid coach. USC is, of course, a major storyline with pressure on Lincoln Riley to produce results this year. Always keep an eye on teams that come from behind, too—like Texas Tech last year; could be SMU this season.
Q: How do you feel about the Kiffin recruiting controversy?
A: Lane is definitely a polarizing figure in coaching. Personally, I think he’s a solid coach and recruiter. The issues surrounding college football and recruiting are complex, and I hope there will be a resolution to some of these concerns. Lane knows he has a genuine chance to build a national contender and is eager to achieve success as head coach.
Q: Any players you’re excited to watch?
A: I’m really looking forward to seeing Cam Coleman play; he’s going to be a standout. Also, keep an eye on Kayden Dixon-Wyatt at USC—he’s a fresh face with great potential. Jordan Davison from Oregon and Rocco Becht at Penn State are also names to note; Rocco’s journey is one fans will appreciate.
Q: Overall thoughts on this college football season?
A: Fall is my favorite season, primarily because football returns. There’s so much change happening within college sports—some good, some not so much. But ultimately, I love celebrating the game itself, the traditions, and the stories that come to life on the field. This year promises to be thrilling; the competition is stronger than ever, and I believe it will be an exciting season.
Q: One word that comes to mind: Kurt Warner.
A: Hall of Fame.
Q: Pete Carroll?
A: Legendary.
Q: Jordan Palmer?
A: Guru.
Q: Winning the 2004 Heisman?
A: It was life-changing. Winning that award is something that sticks with you—I’m grateful to be part of that elite group and what it stands for both on and off the field.
Q: Reflecting on your childhood struggles?
A: It wasn’t easy for me. I faced a lot of teasing growing up; I had some awkward moments, but sports helped me cope. I eventually grew taller and morphed into a much better athlete.
Q: How do you view your NFL career?
A: I wouldn’t say I lived up to my expectations, but I learned and grew from the experience. While injury setbacks were frustrating, I’ve found peace with my career choices. Football opened many doors for me, and I hold no regrets, though I might have wanted a longer career.
Q: The selection process: Did you think the Jets might choose you at No. 4?
A: I genuinely thought there was a chance. There was a lot of hype, and they seemed interested. Ultimately, they opted for D’Brickashaw Ferguson, which worked out for them.
Q: If you could have dinner with three guests?
A: I’d pick Kobe Bryant, Eminem, and Michael Jackson.
Q: Favorite movie?
A: “Wedding Crashers.”
Q: Favorite actor?
A: Jerry Ferrara.
Q: Favorite actress?
A: Josie Loren.
Q: Favorite meal?
A: Cheeseburger and fries, any day.
Q: Final Four predictions?
A: I’m thinking Oregon, Ohio State, Notre Dame—with a nod to Texas.
Q: So who’s going to win it all?
A: I’ll go with Ohio State. They have a strong team with returning players like Julian Sayin and Jeremiah Smith. Plus, I believe they’ve made the right coaching decisions. I don’t foresee them slowing down at all.
