Pochettino Defends Email Notification for World Cup Roster

Manager Mauricio Pochettino has responded to criticism regarding his choice to inform players via email about their exclusion from the U.S. roster for the 2026 World Cup in the United States.

On Friday, members of the 55-man provisional U.S. squad received emails notifying them of their status for the final selection. Some observers criticized the USMNT representatives for what they perceived as a cold approach to delivering such disappointing news.

During a roster announcement event at Pier 17 in Manhattan on Tuesday, Pochettino stood by his decision. He drew from his own experiences as a player when he was left off Argentina’s national team, reflecting on how he handled disappointing news himself.

“I was a player. When I didn’t make the roster, I didn’t want to call the coach,” he stated. He emphasized the challenge of explaining to players why they weren’t selected, acknowledging that it’s tough to say, “The reason is I believe another teammate is a better option right now.” He added that players might become better over time but felt the selection process must continue based on current capabilities.

Pochettino went on to clarify that receiving the decision doesn’t indicate a lack of care. He noted that they practice empathy and consideration for the players’ feelings. He mentioned comparing the situation to being let go from Tottenham and expressed understanding of the emotional weight involved.

“I haven’t been able to sleep for two weeks, thinking about the players who are leaving,” he said, stressing that this isn’t merely about the final 26 players. He feels a responsibility to communicate openly, even if it’s complicated.

The situation sparked a variety of opinions among soccer fans in the U.S. as the World Cup approaches, reflecting broader emotions surrounding the team’s journey.

Former USMNT player and current commentator Hercules Gomez criticized Pochettino on social media and during an episode of ESPN+’s “Football Americas.” He articulated that for players, receiving news of such a significant moment through an email felt inadequate, saying, “They deserve so much more.”

Conversely, others supported the handling of the situation without agreeing on a single approach to communication. Fox Soccer analyst and ex-USMNT player Alexi Lalas, while backing Pochettino, seemed to challenge players who expressed a need for more personal interaction following the news.

“Yes, this is not AYSO,” he noted, alluding to the expectations placed on professional athletes. “Players will always find something to criticize about how the news is delivered.”