Millions could lose benefits they paid for because Congress has ignored Social Security warnings for decades

Millions could lose benefits they paid for because Congress has ignored Social Security warnings for decades

A group of prominent economists, including a Nobel Peace Prize laureate, warned Congress decades ago that changes to Social Security could put the program on an unsustainable path. Today, some experts say those warnings were borne out as the retirement system approaches a funding crisis that could affect millions of people.

Social Security benefits have largely been governed by rules set in 1977, said Andrew Biggs, a senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute. Since then, he said, Congress has done little to address the program’s long-term finances.

A report released by Senate Budget Committee Chair Ron Johnson, a Wisconsin Republican, describes Social Security as a “Ponzi scheme” and traces its financial troubles to decisions made in the 1970s. At the time, lawmakers chose to link benefit increases to wage growth rather than inflation, despite warnings from an expert panel.

According to Johnson’s report, the panel cautioned that tying benefits to inflation instead could have left the system on a more sustainable footing. Congress nevertheless approved its own changes, which President Jimmy Carter signed into law in December 1977.

Biggs said the wage-based formula made benefits grow faster than the program could afford, effectively promising payments that would require future taxpayers to contribute more than people at the time were prepared to pay.

Romina Boccia, who directs budget and entitlement policy at the Cato Institute, said lawmakers have largely avoided reform because of the political risks. She also said many Americans mistakenly view Social Security as a retirement savings account. In reality, she explained, it is a pay-as-you-go system: today’s workers fund benefits for current retirees, rather than building up invested assets for their own retirement.

That structure has come under increasing pressure as the number of workers supporting each retiree has fallen, in part because of declining fertility rates.

Biggs said the last major successful effort to shore up Social Security came in the early 1980s, when Congress raised taxes and increased the retirement age to address an approaching funding shortfall. Lawmakers acted with little time to spare, he said, and may again be forced to intervene as the trust fund approaches depletion, currently projected for 2032.

If the trust fund runs out, Social Security would still collect revenue, but it would not be enough to pay scheduled benefits in full. Benefit reductions could follow, or Congress could cover the gap at a substantial cost to the federal budget and national debt.

Johnson’s report argues that decades of delay have left little room to solve the problem before the fund runs dry. It points toward preventing automatic benefit cuts as the trust fund nears insolvency. Biggs, who took part in President George W. Bush’s Social Security reform effort, said action taken 25 years ago could have addressed the shortfall with changes that were barely noticeable. Today, he said, there is no easy fix, largely because Congress repeatedly postponed decisions for political reasons.

Boccia said lawmakers are unlikely to allow major benefit cuts to take effect, given the political backlash they would provoke. She expects Congress to seek another approach, potentially including tax increases. In 1982, lawmakers responded to a similar crisis with a combination of higher taxes and reduced benefits, including a gradual increase in the retirement age. The funding gap facing the program now, she said, is more than twice as large as it was then.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News