NFL 2027 draft prediction: Four quarterbacks picked in the first round, with an Arch Manning twist

NFL 2027 draft prediction: Four quarterbacks picked in the first round, with an Arch Manning twist

It’s that time of year again—not just for the holidays, but for mock drafts, too.

With the NFL trade deadline behind us and the season past its midpoint, the outline of the 2027 first round is starting to emerge. The teams likely to pick near the top are becoming clearer, along with their needs and the prospects who could fill them.

Here’s an early look at how the first round might unfold, followed by a few thoughts on the picks.

  1. Tennessee Titans — Jeremiah Smith, WR, Ohio State
  2. New York Jets (via Chargers) — Drew Mestemaker, QB, Oklahoma State
  3. Miami Dolphins — Colin Simmons, EDGE, Texas
  4. Los Angeles Chargers (via Jets) — Charlie Becker, WR, Indiana
  5. Philadelphia Eagles — Dylan Stewart, EDGE, South Carolina
  6. New York Jets (via Colts) — Leonard Moore, CB, Notre Dame
  7. Arizona Cardinals — Dylan Mensah, QB, Miami
  8. Atlanta Falcons — Trevor Goosby, OT, Texas
  9. Houston Texans — Jadan Baugh, RB, Florida
  10. Tampa Bay Buccaneers — Chris Cole, LB, Georgia
  11. New Orleans Saints — Will Echoles, DT, Ole Miss
  12. Washington Commanders — Jordan Seaton, OT, LSU
  13. Los Angeles Chargers (via Jets) — Ashton Hampton, CB, Clemson
  14. Baltimore Ravens — Ellis Robinson IV, CB, Georgia
  15. Las Vegas Raiders — Kyngstoon Viliamu-Asa, LB, Notre Dame
  16. New England Patriots — Kade Pieper, IOL, Georgia
  17. Seattle Seahawks — Clev Lubin, EDGE, Louisville
  18. Cleveland Browns (via Rams) — Dante Moore, QB, Oregon
  19. Carolina Panthers — Luke Reynolds, TE, Virginia Tech
  20. Cleveland Browns — Xavier Gilliam, DT, Tennessee
  21. Dallas Cowboys (via Packers) — A.J. Holmes Jr., DT, Texas Tech
  22. New York Giants — Trevor Lauck, OT, Iowa
  23. Pittsburgh Steelers — Cam Coleman, WR, Texas
  24. Denver Broncos — Zereoue Williams, OT, Utah
  25. Cincinnati Bengals — Brauntae Johnson, S, Notre Dame
  26. Philadelphia Eagles (via Jaguars) — Elijah Paige, OT, USC
  27. Minnesota Vikings — CJ Carr, QB, Notre Dame
  28. Tennessee Titans (via Bears) — A’Mauri Washington, DT, Oregon
  29. Kansas City Chiefs — Cayden Green, OT, Missouri
  30. Detroit Lions — Will Heldt, EDGE, Clemson
  31. San Francisco 49ers — Boubacar Traore, EDGE, Notre Dame
  32. Buffalo Bills — Jamari Johnson, TE, Oregon

A trade near the top

The biggest move in this projection has the Jets trading up to No. 2 to take Oklahoma State quarterback Drew Mestemaker.

New York has three first-round picks, but if Mestemaker is its preferred quarterback, the Jets may need to get in front of Miami at No. 3. Their picks at No. 4 and No. 13 could help make that happen, while the team would still have the sixth pick, acquired from Indianapolis in the Sauce Gardner trade. Here, the Jets use that selection on Notre Dame cornerback Leonard Moore.

There’s an obvious question, though: is it wise to trade up for a quarterback who didn’t start for his high school team and is only in his first season starting at a Power Four school?

Mestemaker has a lot going for him. He can push the ball downfield, move well, attack tight windows over the middle and vary the touch on his throws. His limited starting experience is a concern, but it also makes his progress so far striking. His upside is enormous, and I’ve been increasingly impressed with him.

The Chargers come away with Indiana receiver Charlie Becker, a new target for Justin Herbert, and Clemson cornerback Ashton Hampton to help shore up the secondary.

Where does Arch Manning fit?

That’s likely to be one of the biggest questions as draft season develops. With Thanksgiving approaching, I’m not convinced Manning will declare.

His performance against LSU resembled his outings against Ole Miss and Ohio State earlier in the season: flashes of excellent play late, after some tougher stretches. He could still enter the draft, and it will be fascinating to see how evaluators rank him against the rest of this class. For now, I think returning to Texas—or perhaps considering the transfer portal—seems more likely than heading to the NFL.

What about the other quarterbacks?

Two quarterbacks left out of this first-round projection are Austin Simmons and Trinidad Chambliss. Like Manning, I expect Simmons to return to Missouri for another season. He has reportedly signed a new deal with the school for 2027, though he still has the option to enter the draft. After Missouri’s recent struggles, another year on campus could make sense.

I like Chambliss, but it’s hard to know whether NFL teams will evaluate him as highly as I do. He could fall into the early part of the second round, which wouldn’t necessarily be a bad outcome.

Dante Moore is the next quarterback off the board in this mock, going to Cleveland at No. 18. Deshaun Watson has steadied the position this season, but the Browns still need a long-term answer. Moore was considered a possible top-five pick a year ago, and the talent remains evident.

At No. 27, Minnesota takes CJ Carr. He could suit Kevin O’Connell’s offense, and the pick raises the possibility of Kirk Cousins mentoring another first-round quarterback. I keep imagining a sort of “Mandalorian” setup: Cousins joins a team, guides its rookie quarterback, then moves on to another surprise playoff contender with a glaring need at the position. A hired gun in a spaghetti Western, year after year.

That’s probably enough of that. Still, it could make a television series.

A running back in the top 10?

I know it’s a bold choice, but the more I considered Jadan Baugh in Houston, the more the fit made sense.

Kansas City offers a recent example of how a running back can change an offense. The Chiefs added Kenneth Walker III in the offseason, and his explosiveness has helped stabilize their ground game and made them one of the AFC’s top teams again.

Houston could use a boost in that area. Some of the numbers depend on game situation, but the Texans rank 29th in rushing yards per game and 24th in expected points added per rush.

An offensive lineman would also be a reasonable choice for Houston. Baugh, though, brings the ability to make plays as both a runner and a receiver, which makes him an intriguing fit.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News