NWSL Player Calls for Gender Standards, Sparking Division Among Teams

There’s a significant divide among the clubs in the National Women’s Soccer League (NWSL) after player Elizabeth Eddy urged the league to establish “gender standards” aimed at safeguarding the health of the organization and promoting growth in women’s soccer.

In her recent column, Eddy posed a critical question: “How do we preserve women’s rights and competitive fairness while promoting meaningful inclusion?” She emphasized that the existing controversies in swimming and track and field illustrate the absence of clear guidelines in women’s professional soccer, particularly regarding intersex and transgender athletes. Eddy suggested that the NWSL should implement distinct standards, advocating for rules similar to those of the British Women’s Super League, which would permit only players born with ovaries to compete. Alternatively, she proposed that the league explore SRY genetic testing, akin to practices in World Athletics and World Boxing.

Eddy remarked, “Fairness and inclusion are core American values. Reasonable people may disagree on where to draw the line, but shutting off diverse voices and avoiding the conversation altogether does not serve us. In fact, we owe it to our current and future female athletes to fix this issue.”

However, her opinions did not resonate well with some teammates. Sarah Gorden and Angelina Anderson expressed their strong disapproval.

Gorden articulated the feelings within the team, stating, “That article doesn’t represent this team in this locker room. I’ve had a lot of conversations with my teammates recently, and they’re hurt by the article.” She accused Eddy’s column of being harmful, suggesting it could be viewed as transphobic and racially insensitive. Gorden further emphasized that the notion of genetic testing for some athletes, juxtaposed with imagery of an African athlete, perpetuates harmful stereotypes.

Anderson provided her input regarding the club’s values, saying, “For me personally, when I think of L.A. and Angel City, I think of a place that was founded on inclusivity and love for all people.” She affirmed that Angel City FC aims to be a welcoming environment for everyone.

Addressing the timing of the controversy, Anderson added, “It feels like another big challenge for us as a team to overcome in an already very difficult year.” She highlighted the importance of unity within the team and expressed a dedication to maintaining respect and belonging as they approach the end of the season.

The NWSL also weighed in on Eddy’s column, stating their commitment to collaborating with the NWSL Players Association on any policy changes moving forward.