Research reveals CNN and MSNBC’s 211 assertions of ‘peaceful’ anti-ICE demonstrations

Media Study on Anti-ICE Protests

A recent analysis from the Media Research Center suggests that CNN and MSNBC consistently described the anti-ICE protests as “almost peaceful,” despite evidence of chaos and unrest. The findings have sparked some debate about media coverage of such events.

In Los Angeles, a series of protests devolved into chaos, with incidents of mob looting prompting significant law enforcement responses, including mass arrests. Videos of these events circulated widely on social media, showing a stark contrast between the protests and the businesses affected.

Similar confrontations unfolded in New York City, where police vehicles were damaged during protests. In Chicago, large groups of demonstrators gathered, leading to further destruction of property and clashes with law enforcement.

The Media Research Center’s study, which reviewed coverage from June 7 to June 11, identified 211 instances where CNN and MSNBC labeled the protests as “largely peaceful” or similar phrases. Of these, CNN accounted for 123 mentions, while MSNBC had 88.

Protests occurred not just in major cities like Los Angeles, New York, and Chicago, but also in states including North Carolina, Texas, and Georgia. Yet, the two networks continued to portray the demonstrations with an emphasis on their peaceful nature.

Bill Agostino, a senior research analyst involved in the study, noted that whenever violence occurred, CNN and MSNBC tended to describe it as being caused by separate groups, distancing it from the peaceful protesters. This framing, he argues, downplays the connection between the two factions.

Notably, Agostino pointed out a lack of acknowledgment from reporters regarding the mobilization of the National Guard and military forces to address the violent elements of the protests. Concerns were raised about the use of such force against what were described as “peaceful” gatherings.

This presents a complex picture of how these events are portrayed in the media, raising questions about the relationship between protest actions and their coverage.