Michelin-Starred Restaurant Faces Health Violations
Sema, a Michelin-starred restaurant, is under scrutiny for several health violations, particularly for not displaying its “B” cleanliness rating where customers can see it, according to recent reports.
Located in the West Village, known for being one of the toughest reservations to snag in New York City, Sema was flagged during its last inspection in January. The restaurant racked up multiple health complaints, including concerns over food temperatures, personal cleanliness, and potential contamination.
The inspection revealed that the restaurant didn’t have its “B” rating visibly posted, which goes against city regulations. The city’s health department maintains a publicly accessible website that tracks such results.
A recent visit to Sema confirmed that the rating sign was still not displayed prominently, and it appears the restaurant will retain this rating until at least 2024.
A representative for Sema disputed claims that the rating was hidden, stating that it was properly posted, while also criticizing the health department’s findings during the inspection.
“According to the Department of Health’s inspection cycle, places rated B are supposed to be re-inspected roughly five to seven months after the initial visit, and Sema is currently within that timeframe,” he explained. “If there’s a delay, it’s because of the city’s scheduling, not due to any wrongdoing by Sema.”
Addressing the issue of signage, he stated, “We operate properly and maintain a clean establishment.”
Yet, a look around the restaurant—and even discussions on platforms like Reddit—showed that the sign may have been obscured or placed out of sight.
The health department requires all eateries to keep their ratings displayed in a location that is easy for guests to see. One Reddit commenter noted the rating was “hidden in a corner of a small window” and away from street view.
Another user voiced frustration, suggesting that the high cost of dining—over $100 per person—should be matched with transparency regarding health ratings.
In response to the findings, the site manager insisted that the 8×11 letter grade is usually in a smaller side window but quickly moved the sign to a more visible spot facing the street when asked by a reporter.
This issue comes on the heels of another report about the popular restaurant Carbone, which was also found with a concealed rating. Other well-known eateries, like Serafina and Cafe Dante, were noted for either hiding their ratings or displaying outdated notices.
Sema, which opened in 2021, received 18 points on its last inspection, with officials pointing out that food, supplies, and equipment were not adequately protected from contamination risks. There were also observations of personal cleanliness issues and concerns related to attire and jewelry.
The most recent public inspection report shows similar violation counts, including sightings of pests and conditions favoring a rodent population.
Health code scores are categorized, with A ratings for scores between 0-13, B for 14-27, and C grades for scores of 28 or more, which often point to serious hygiene issues.
New Yorkers have varied opinions on whether they would still dine at Sema after hearing about these violations. Some expressed concern, while others felt the food quality might justify the dining experience.
“I probably wouldn’t go back. It’s a bit concerning,” remarked a local, Alex Haskett. “But if someone else picks it, I might still join; it’s just something I’d think about.” Another passerby mentioned that a good meal could outweigh the health grade, especially in a city where Michelin stars are valued. Some diners who had previously enjoyed the restaurant expressed surprise and noted that their experiences had been positive and clean, though they acknowledged the long wait times involved.
